Al-Ḥasan ibn ʿAlī, called al-ʿAskarī after the garrison quarter of Sāmarrāʾ where he spent nearly all his life, was the eleventh Imam. He led the Shia for only six years (868–874), much of the time under arrest or close watch, reaching his followers through letters and a few trusted agents. He died at about twenty-eight. Whether he left a son became the defining question of Twelver Shiism. The Twelvers hold that he had a son, Muḥammad, born in 869 and hidden from the authorities, and that this son is the twelfth Imam and the awaited Mahdī. Most Sunnis, and some Shia of the time, held that he died without a son.
Life
Shia traditionSunni tradition
Birth
He was born in Medina in Rabīʿ al-Thānī 232 AH (December 846), on the 8th by the common Shia date; others give Ramaḍān 232, or the year 231. His mother, a slave woman named Ḥudayth or Sūsan, is called al-Jadda, “the grandmother”, in Shia sources. After his son's disappearance she served as the family's link to the Shia. He was taken to Sāmarrāʾ as a small child when his father was summoned there, and grew up in al-ʿAskar.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 · al-Mufīd, al-Irshād · al-Ṭūsī, al-Ghayba
Shia hadithHistory
The unexpected heir
His elder brother Muḥammad had been widely expected to succeed their father, and died in 252 AH. Al-Kāfī reports al-Hādī telling al-Ḥasan to give thanks, for God had brought forth a new matter through him. The Shia theologians later discussed this case under the heading of badāʾ, the change of what seemed decreed. Some followers turned to his younger brother Jaʿfar, who claimed the Imamate after al-Ḥasan's death and whom the Twelvers call al-Kadhdhāb, “the liar”.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 · al-Ṭūsī, al-Ghayba · al-Nawbakhtī, Firaq al-shīʿa
Shia traditionHistory
Under watch and in prison
The caliphs al-Muʿtazz, al-Muhtadī and al-Muʿtamid kept him under watch and imprisoned him more than once. Al-Mufīd tells that the Turkish commander Ṣāliḥ b. Waṣīf set two of his harshest men to guard him. They became so devout from watching him that they could no longer face their master. Shia sources say he received visitors rarely and in secret, and that he forbade his followers to greet him, or even to make a sign to him, when he rode to the palace, since it would put their lives in danger.
al-Mufīd, al-Irshād · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1
Shia hadithSunni tradition
A courtier's praise
Al-Kāfī and al-Mufīd report a striking testimony from Aḥmad b. ʿUbaydullāh b. Khāqān, an ʿAbbāsid tax official and son of a vizier, known for his hostility to the ʿAlids. He said he had never seen or known in Sāmarrāʾ any of the family of ʿAlī like al-Ḥasan b. ʿAlī in dignity, modesty, nobility and standing with his own family, the ruler and all the Banū Hāshim. He told how his father, the vizier, had seated the young man in his own place and treated him with a respect he showed to no one else.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 · al-Mufīd, al-Irshād
Teaching
HistoryShia tradition
Agents in a hidden age
With access to him so restricted, he worked almost entirely through agents and correspondence. His chief agent, ʿUthmān b. Saʿīd al-ʿAmrī, is said to have traded in clarified butter (samn), hence his name al-Sammān, as a cover, carrying letters and funds in its skins. Aḥmad b. Isḥāq al-Ashʿarī was his agent in Qom. Many of his rulings survive as answers to written questions (tawqīʿāt). Historians see the Occultation of his son as a continuation of this system of indirect leadership, rather than a sudden break.
al-Ṭūsī, al-Ghayba · J. M. Hussain, The Occultation of the Twelfth Imam (1982) · H. Modarressi, Crisis and Consolidation (1993)
Shia traditionHistory
Al-Kindī's book
Ibn Shahrāshūb tells that the philosopher al-Kindī began writing a book on the contradictions of the Qurʾan. Al-ʿAskarī asked one of al-Kindī's students to put a single question to him. If someone recited the Qurʾan to him, could he allow that the speaker had meant something other than what al-Kindī took the words to mean? Al-Kindī granted that this was possible, realised that his whole argument assumed he knew the speaker's meaning, and burned the book. Ibn Shahrāshūb cites it from the tenth-century Abū l-Qāsim al-Kūfī; no earlier source is known, and some modern Shia scholars, such as Murtaḍā Muṭahharī, have doubted it.
Ibn Shahrāshūb, Manāqib Āl Abī Ṭālib 4
Shia hadithShia tradition
The signs of the believer
Al-Ṭūsī transmits from him a hadith listing five signs of a believer:
- praying fifty-one units of prayer a day, the obligatory and supererogatory together;
- the Arbaʿīn visitation, usually understood as that of al-Ḥusayn;
- wearing a ring on the right hand;
- pressing the forehead to the earth in prostration;
- reciting “In the name of God” aloud in prayer.
Several of these mark visible differences between Shia and Sunni practice. The hadith is one of the main textual bases for the Arbaʿīn pilgrimage.
al-Ṭūsī, Tahdhīb al-aḥkām 6 · al-Ṭūsī, Miṣbāḥ al-mutahajjid
Shia hadithTafsir
The Tafsīr of the ʿAskarī
A Qurʾan commentary on al-Fātiḥa and most of al-Baqara, al-Tafsīr al-mansūb ilā l-Imām al-ʿAskarī, “the commentary attributed to Imam al-ʿAskarī”, is said to have been dictated by him to two young men from Astarābād. Al-Ṣadūq used it, and al-Majlisī included much of it in the Biḥār. But the critic Ibn al-Ghaḍāʾirī rejected it as a forgery, and many Shia scholars, past and present, doubt its authenticity. It is rich in stories of the Prophet's miracles and of the virtues of the Imams.
al-Tafsīr al-mansūb ilā l-Imām al-ʿAskarī · Ibn al-Ghaḍāʾirī, al-Rijāl · M. M. Bar-Asher, Scripture and Exegesis in Early Imāmī Shiism (1999)
Shia traditionChristian tradition
The monk who brought rain
Later Shia sources tell that during a drought in Sāmarrāʾ the Muslims prayed for rain without effect. Then a Christian monk raised his hand to the sky and rain fell, and many began to doubt their faith. The caliph sent for al-ʿAskarī, who had the monk's hand opened. Between his fingers was a bone of one of the prophets, through which, he explained, any hand raised to heaven would bring rain. When the bone was taken away the monk's prayer failed. The story, in al-Rāwandī and Ibn Shahrāshūb, defends the Muslims' faith while granting the power of a holy relic.
Quṭb al-Dīn al-Rāwandī, al-Kharāʾij wa-l-jarāʾiḥ · Ibn Shahrāshūb, Manāqib Āl Abī Ṭālib 4
Death and the question of a son
Shia traditionSunni tradition
Death
He fell ill and died in Sāmarrāʾ on 8 Rabīʿ al-Awwal 260 AH (1 January 874), aged about twenty-eight. Shia sources say he was poisoned on the orders of al-Muʿtamid. Al-Kāfī and al-Ṣadūq report that, as he lay ill, the caliph sent physicians, judges and officials to watch the house day and night. After his death the caliph's brother Abū ʿĪsā led a public funeral prayer and showed the uncovered face to the notables, so that all could witness he had died a natural death. He was buried beside his father.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Mufīd, al-Irshād
Shia hadithHistory
The inheritance and the search
No son was presented, so the estate was divided between his mother and his brother Jaʿfar. Al-Ṣadūq reports that the authorities searched the house and kept his slave women under watch for signs of pregnancy, one of them, Ṣaqīl, for two years. Shia sources tell that when Jaʿfar was about to lead the private funeral prayer, a small boy came forward. He pulled at Jaʿfar's robe, said he had more right to lead it, and led the prayer himself. Twelvers identify the boy as the son, Muḥammad, the twelfth Imam.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, al-Ghayba
HistoryShia tradition
The perplexity
His death without a visible heir threw the Shia into what their own writers called the ḥayra, “perplexity”. Al-Nawbakhtī, writing within a few decades, lists some fourteen groups among his followers; other counts run as high as twenty. Some held that he had not died and would return; some followed Jaʿfar. Some said the Imamate had ended, some that there was a hidden son. Over the next century the belief in a hidden son, the twelfth Imam, prevailed and gave the Twelvers their name.
al-Nawbakhtī, Firaq al-shīʿa · al-Ashʿarī al-Qummī, al-Maqālāt wa-l-firaq · H. Modarressi, Crisis and Consolidation (1993)
Shia hadithChristian tradition
Narjis, the Byzantine princess
Al-Ṣadūq's Kamāl al-dīn preserves the story of the twelfth Imam's mother, Narjis (also called Malīka, Ṣaqīl or Sawsan). In it she is a Byzantine princess, a granddaughter of the emperor, descended through her mother from the apostle Simon Peter. Guided by dreams of Mary and Fāṭima, she lets herself be captured by Muslim raiders, and is bought in Baghdad on al-Hādī's instructions. Other reports say only that she was a slave woman born in the household. The story is treated in full under the Mahdī.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, al-Ghayba
Sunni tradition
Sunni views
Sunni biographers give him short entries. Al-Dhahabī says he was one of the noble ʿAlids, and that the Shia claim he had a son who went into hiding. Most Sunni scholars, among them Ibn Ḥazm, hold that he left no son. A minority of Sunni scholars, such as Ibn Ṭalḥa al-Shāfiʿī, Sibṭ b. al-Jawzī and al-Ganjī al-Shāfiʿī, accepted that the Mahdī was his son.
al-Dhahabī, Siyar aʿlām al-nubalāʾ 13 · Ibn Khallikān, Wafayāt al-aʿyān 2 · Ibn Ṭalḥa, Maṭālib al-saʾūl · Sibṭ b. al-Jawzī, Tadhkirat al-khawāṣṣ
Across the traditions
Author's note · comparing traditions
Jewish traditionChurch FathersShia tradition
The burned book: reading scripture with charity
The al-Kindī story turns on a simple point: before you call a scripture self-contradictory, you must be sure you know what its author meant. Interpreters in the other traditions made a similar rule:
- Christianity. Augustine urged readers of the Bible to prefer whatever reading builds up love, and to take as figurative whatever, read literally, accords neither with good morals nor with true faith (On Christian Teaching 3).
- Judaism. In the introduction to his Guide of the Perplexed, Maimonides lists seven causes of contradiction in a book. He traces the apparent contradictions in the prophetic books to figurative speech and to unstated conditions or shifts of subject (his third and fourth causes), not to error.
The Shia story gives the rule a further turn. Only the Imam, as heir to the Prophet's knowledge, can be sure what the speaker meant.
Augustine, On Christian Teaching 3 · Maimonides, Guide of the Perplexed, Introduction · Ibn Shahrāshūb, Manāqib Āl Abī Ṭālib 4
Author's note · comparing traditions
Hebrew BibleTalmudChristian traditionShia tradition
Rainmakers and relics: Elisha's bones and Ḥoni's circle
The story of the Christian monk and the prophet's bone brings together two ancient themes:
- The holy rainmaker. Elijah's prayer on Carmel ends a drought (1 Kings 18:41–45). The Talmud tells of Ḥoni the circle-drawer, who drew a circle on the ground and vowed not to leave it until God sent rain (Taʿanit 23a).
- The power of a prophet's remains. In the Bible, a dead man thrown into Elisha's tomb comes back to life when he touches the prophet's bones (2 Kings 13:21). Christians long cited this verse in defence of honouring relics.
The Shia story accepts that a prophet's bone holds such power, and objects only that the rain proved the bone's holiness, not the truth of the monk's faith.
1 Kings 18:41–45 · 2 Kings 13:21 · Babylonian Talmud, Taʿanit 23a · Quṭb al-Dīn al-Rāwandī, al-Kharāʾij wa-l-jarāʾiḥ