Twelver Shia believe that Muḥammad, son of the eleventh Imam, al-Ḥasan al-ʿAskarī, was born in Sāmarrāʾ in 869 and hidden from the ʿAbbāsid authorities. When his father died in 874 he withdrew from sight. For seventy years he guided his followers through four deputies in turn, and since 941 he has been in the “Major Occultation”, alive but unseen. At the end of time he will appear as the Mahdī, “the rightly guided one”, with Jesus at his side, and fill the earth with justice as it has been filled with injustice. Belief in a Mahdī from the Prophet's family is shared by most Sunnis. They hold, though, that he has not yet been born. Other movements have proclaimed their own Mahdīs, and the Bābī and Baháʼí faiths grew out of a claim to fulfil the expectation. The hope has close relatives in the Jewish Messiah, the Christian Second Coming and the Zoroastrian saviour.
Birth
Shia hadithShia tradition
The hidden birth
Twelver sources date his birth to the night of 15 Shaʿbān 255 AH (July 869) in Sāmarrāʾ. The best-known account, in al-Ṣadūq's Kamāl al-dīn and al-Ṭūsī's al-Ghayba, is told by Ḥakīma, daughter of the ninth Imam and aunt of al-ʿAskarī. Her nephew asked her to stay the night. She saw no sign of pregnancy in his wife Narjis, until near dawn the child was born. Al-ʿAskarī took the baby, who recited the profession of faith and the names of the Imams. The birth was kept secret because, the sources say, the ʿAbbāsids knew of hadith that the twelfth Imam would be the Qāʾim and were watching for him. Al-ʿAskarī is said to have shown the child to a few trusted followers. Aḥmad b. Isḥāq of Qom was one of them.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn wa-tamām al-niʿma · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 (Bāb mawlid al-Ṣāḥib)
Shia hadithShia tradition
Names and titles
His name is Muḥammad and his kunya Abū l-Qāsim, the same as the Prophet's. Several Shia hadith forbid saying his name aloud until he appears, so devotional texts often write it as separate letters, M-Ḥ-M-D. He is called by titles instead:
- al-Qāʾim, “the one who will rise”;
- al-Ḥujja, “the proof” of God on earth;
- Ṣāḥib al-Zamān or Imām-i Zamān, “the master of the age”;
- al-Muntaẓar, “the awaited”;
- Baqiyyat Allāh, “what God has left in reserve”, after Q 11:86.
When his title al-Qāʾim is spoken, many Shia rise to their feet and place a hand on their head.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 (Bāb fī l-nahy ʿan al-ism) · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · Qurʾan 11:86
Shia hadithChristian tradition
Narjis, the princess of Rūm
Al-Ṣadūq preserves a long story of the Mahdī's mother, told by Bishr b. Sulaymān, a slave dealer and follower of al-Hādī. In it she is Malīka, daughter of Yashūʿā, son of the Byzantine emperor. Through her mother she descends from Shamʿūn, Simon Peter, the successor of Jesus. Her wedding to the emperor's nephew collapses when the throne and the crosses fall. Then in a dream she sees Muhammad come with his family to Jesus and Shamʿūn and ask for her hand for al-ʿAskarī. Jesus consents, and Muhammad marries her to him with Jesus as witness. Mary and Fāṭima come to her in later dreams, and she becomes a Muslim in secret. Following a dream, she joins a Byzantine army disguised as a servant, is captured, and is sold in Baghdad. Bishr buys her there, carrying a letter from al-Hādī written in Greek. Other reports call her simply a slave woman of the household, and give names such as Sawsan, Rayḥāna and Ṣaqīl. Historians find no trace of her in Byzantine sources, and many Shia scholars treat the story's chain as weak.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1
Sunni hadithShia hadith
Twelve successors
Al-Bukhārī and Muslim report from Jābir b. Samura that the Prophet said there would be twelve rulers (amīrs or khalīfas), all of them from Quraysh (Bukhārī 7222; Muslim 1821). Sunni commentators have offered many lists of the twelve: the first four caliphs and selected Umayyads, or just rulers before the faith weakens. Shia scholars hold that only the twelve Imams fit, and that the twelfth must therefore still be alive. The name Ithnā ʿashariyya, “Twelvers”, came into general use in the 10th century, as the belief in a twelfth and final Imam became settled.
Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 7222 · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1821 · E. Kohlberg, “From Imāmiyya to Ithnā-ʿashariyya” (BSOAS 39, 1976)
The Minor Occultation, 874–941
Shia traditionHistory
The four deputies
After al-ʿAskarī's death the Twelvers held that the hidden Imam spoke through a single deputy at a time (nāʾib or safīr, “envoy”). There were four:
- ʿUthmān b. Saʿīd al-ʿAmrī, the agent of the two previous Imams;
- his son Muḥammad b. ʿUthmān, for about fifty years by al-Ṭūsī's count (some forty by modern reckoning), until 305/917;
- al-Ḥusayn b. Rawḥ al-Nawbakhtī, of a prominent Baghdad family close to the ʿAbbāsid court, until 326/938;
- ʿAlī b. Muḥammad al-Samarrī, for three years, until 329/941.
The deputies received the community's questions and dues, and passed on written answers in the Imam's name (tawqīʿāt). Al-Ṭūsī and al-Ṣadūq quote many of these letters. Modern historians, such as Jassim Hussain, see the deputies as continuing the agent network of the late Imams.
al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · J. M. Hussain, The Occultation of the Twelfth Imam (1982)
Shia traditionHistory
Rival claimants
Others also claimed to be the Imam's gate (bāb). Al-Ṭūsī lists and condemns several, among them Muḥammad b. Nuṣayr, eponym of the Nuṣayrīs (Alawites), and the Sufi al-Ḥallāj. The best-documented case is Muḥammad b. ʿAlī al-Shalmaghānī. He had been a colleague of the third deputy and later claimed divine indwelling. Ibn Rawḥ issued a letter in the Imam's name cursing him, and the ʿAbbāsid authorities executed him in 934.
al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · Encyclopaedia of Islam, 2nd ed., “al-Shalmaghānī”
Shia hadith
The last letter
Al-Ṣadūq and al-Ṭūsī report that six days before al-Samarrī died, he showed his followers a letter from the Imam. It told him that he would die in six days and was to name no successor. The complete occultation had begun, and would last until God permitted the Imam to appear, after long years when hearts grow hard and the earth fills with injustice. Anyone who claimed to have seen him before the appearance of the Sufyānī and the cry from heaven was a liar. By their account, al-Samarrī died on the day foretold, in 329 AH (941).
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba
The Major Occultation
Shia hadithShia tradition
Why he is hidden
Twelver theologians from al-Nuʿmānī (d. c. 971) and al-Ṣadūq to al-Mufīd, al-Murtaḍā and al-Ṭūsī wrote books on the Occultation (al-Ghayba). They argued:
- The Imam hid because, if he appeared, he would be killed. The danger came from the enemies, not from God.
- The world is never without a proof of God, and he remains that proof though unseen.
- He still benefits the world, as the sun does when hidden by clouds. This comparison is attributed to the Imam himself in a letter to Isḥāq b. Yaʿqūb.
- The Occultation is a test of faith for believers.
al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭabarsī, al-Iḥtijāj 2 (the letter to Isḥāq b. Yaʿqūb) · al-Murtaḍā, al-Muqniʿ fī l-ghayba · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba
Shia traditionQurʾan
A very long life
Asked how anyone could live for centuries, Shia scholars pointed to precedents in scripture and tradition. Noah lived among his people nine hundred and fifty years (Q 29:14). Muslims widely hold that al-Khiḍr is still alive, and Jesus was raised alive to heaven and will return (Q 4:157–158). Since al-Ṣadūq, Shia writers have collected accounts of the long-lived (al-muʿammarūn) to show that God can lengthen a life as He wills. Al-Ṣadūq also cites hadith that the Qāʾim will remain youthful, appearing as a man of about forty.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn (bāb al-muʿammarīn) · Qurʾan 29:14; 4:157–158; 18:65–82
Shia hadithShia tradition
Seen by the few
Al-Ṣadūq and al-Ṭūsī report from the second deputy that the Imam attends the pilgrimage every year. He sees the people and knows them, and they see him without knowing him. In a saying of al-Ṣādiq in al-Kāfī, he attends the pilgrimage in one of his occultations, seeing the people while they do not see him. Over the centuries Shia literature has gathered stories of believers who met him in the desert, on the road to Mecca, or in a mosque. Al-Majlisī and Mīrzā Ḥusayn al-Nūrī (d. 1902) collected many in books such as al-Najm al-thāqib. Scholars reconcile these with the last letter by holding that the letter denies only claims to be his deputy, not chance encounters.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār 52–53 · Mīrzā Ḥusayn al-Nūrī, al-Najm al-thāqib
Sunni traditionShia traditionHistory
The cellar of Sāmarrāʾ, and Ḥilla
Sunni polemicists such as Ibn Taymiyya mocked the Shia for supposedly waiting at the cellar (sardāb) of the Imams' house in Sāmarrāʾ, where they said the boy had disappeared. Ibn Khaldūn too reports such a belief, though he places the cellar in their house at Ḥilla. The traveller Ibn Baṭṭūṭa, visiting Ḥilla in 1327, describes a mosque with a curtained doorway called the Shrine of the Master of the Age. Each day after the afternoon prayer, he says, about a hundred armed men led a saddled horse or mule there with drums and trumpets, calling on the Imam to come out, for they believed he had vanished in that mosque. Twelver scholars reply that the cellar is honoured as a place where the Imam prayed, not as where he lives or will emerge. They also say that no doctrine ties his appearance to it.
Ibn Taymiyya, Minhāj al-sunna 1 · Ibn Khaldūn, al-Muqaddima 3 · Ibn Baṭṭūṭa, Tuḥfat al-nuẓẓār (al-Ḥilla)
Shia traditionHistory
Jamkarān, and letters to the Imam
The mosque of Jamkarān near Qom is linked to a tradition that the Imam appeared there to a local man and asked for a mosque to be built. The text dates this to 393 AH (1003), which Jean Calmard argues is a misreading of 373 (984). Since the 1990s it has grown into one of Iran's busiest pilgrimage sites, crowded on Tuesday nights and on 15 Shaʿbān. Pilgrims drop written petitions (ʿarīḍa) to the Imam into a well there, as Shia elsewhere drop them into rivers or wells. In Iraq the Mosque of al-Sahla in Kufa is held to be his future home, and is visited on the eve of Wednesday (Tuesday night). The birthday of 15 Shaʿbān is a festival with lights across the Shia world. In South Asia it coincides with Shab-i Barāt, which Sunnis also keep.
Encyclopaedia Iranica, “Jamkarān” · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār 53 · al-Ṭūsī, Miṣbāḥ al-mutahajjid
Shia hadithShia tradition
Prayers of waiting
Expecting the Imam (intiẓār al-faraj) is itself counted a form of worship. Shia devotion addresses him in several much-recited prayers:
- Duʿāʾ al-Nudba, the “prayer of lament”, recited on Fridays, which asks where the son of the Prophet has gone and longs for his return;
- Duʿāʾ al-ʿAhd, the “prayer of the covenant”, renewing loyalty to him each morning;
- Ziyārat Āl Yāsīn, a greeting to him attributed to a letter of his own;
- the short prayer Allāhumma kun li-waliyyika, “O God, be for your friend…”, recited for his protection.
Ibn al-Mashhadī, al-Mazār al-kabīr · Ibn Ṭāwūs, Iqbāl al-aʿmāl · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār 102
Authority in his absence
Shia hadithShia tradition
“Refer to the transmitters of our hadith”
In a letter preserved by al-Ṣadūq, the Imam tells Isḥāq b. Yaʿqūb to refer new matters to the transmitters of the Imams' hadith. They are his proof to the people, and he is God's proof to them. Over the centuries Twelver jurists read this as making the qualified jurist (mujtahid) the Imam's general deputy. Through it they came to collect the khums, lead the Friday prayer, give judgement and, in some views, rule.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Ṭabarsī, al-Iḥtijāj 2 · N. Calder, “Khums in Imāmī Shīʿī Jurisprudence, from the Tenth to the Sixteenth Century A.D.” (BSOAS 45, 1982)
Shia traditionHistory
Guardianship of the jurist
In lectures given in Najaf in 1970, Ayatollah Khomeini argued for wilāyat al-faqīh, the guardianship of the jurist. On this view, in the Imam's absence, a just jurist holds the governing authority the Imam would hold. Article 5 of the constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran (1979) gives the leadership of the nation “during the Occultation of the Lord of the Age” to a just and pious jurist. Many senior Shia jurists, among them Ayatollah al-Khūʾī and Ayatollah al-Sīstānī in Najaf, have held a narrower view of the jurist's authority. The question remains one of the main fault lines in modern Shia thought.
R. Khomeini, Ḥukūmat-i islāmī (1970), tr. H. Algar, Islam and Revolution (1981) · Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, art. 5 · A. Sachedina, The Just Ruler in Shiʿite Islam (1988)
The return
Shia hadithSunni hadith
Signs
Shia hadith, collected by al-Nuʿmānī, al-Ṣadūq and al-Ṭūsī, name five certain signs before his rising:
- the appearance of the Sufyānī, a tyrant from Syria of the house of Abū Sufyān;
- the Yamānī, a leader from Yemen;
- the cry (ṣayḥa) from heaven calling his name;
- the killing of a pure soul (al-Nafs al-Zakiyya) between the corner of the Kaʿba and the Station of Abraham;
- the swallowing of an army in the desert (al-khasf bi-l-baydāʾ).
Sunni collections also report the army swallowed by the earth (Muslim 2882) and the Sufyānī, in weaker reports. Many further signs are reported, such as an eclipse of the sun in the middle of Ramaḍān and of the moon at its end.
al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2882
Shia hadithSunni hadith
The rising
By Shia hadith he will appear in Mecca, between the corner of the Kaʿba and the Station of Abraham, and three hundred and thirteen companions, the number of the fighters at Badr, will gather to him. He will go to Kufa and make it his capital, defeat the Sufyānī and the oppressors, and avenge al-Ḥusayn. He will fill the earth with justice as it was filled with injustice. Jesus will come down from heaven and pray behind him. The last point is shared with Sunni hadith: Muslim reports that when Jesus descends, the Muslims' leader will invite him to lead the prayer. Jesus will decline, saying that some of them are leaders over others, as an honour from God to this community (Muslim 156). Shia hadith also teach the rajʿa, the return of some of the righteous and the wicked to life before the Resurrection. Al-Ḥusayn is often named first among them.
al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · al-Mufīd, al-Irshād (bāb dhikr ʿalāmāt qiyām al-Qāʾim) · Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3449 · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 156
Shia hadithSunni tradition
“The time-setters lie”
Al-Kāfī reports al-Ṣādiq saying that “the time-setters lie” (kadhaba al-waqqātūn), and that the Imams set no time for the Qāʾim. Shia scholars cite this against anyone who announces a date for his appearance, and Sunni scholars likewise warn against fixing the Hour. Expectation has still run high at certain dates, such as the thousandth Islamic year (1591–92). That year saw messianic movements among both Sunnis and Shia, from the Mughal court of Akbar to Safavid Iran.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 (Bāb karāhiyat al-tawqīt) · al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · A. Moin, The Millennial Sovereign (2012)
The Mahdī in Sunni Islam
Sunni hadith
The Sunni hadith
The Sunni hadith of the Mahdī are found mainly in the Sunan, not in al-Bukhārī or Muslim:
- Abū Dāwūd reports that if only one day of the world remained, God would lengthen it until He sent a man of the Prophet's family. His name would match the Prophet's and his father's name the Prophet's father's, and he would fill the earth with justice (Abū Dāwūd 4282).
- Abū Dāwūd also reports that the Mahdī is of the Prophet's family, from the children of Fāṭima (4284).
- Others say he will have a broad forehead and a hooked nose, rule seven years, and appear after a dispute on a caliph's death (4285–4286). Al-Tirmidhī (2230–2231) and Ibn Mājah (4082–4088) have similar reports.
Most Sunni scholars hold the Mahdī's coming to be firmly established, and some, such as al-Shawkānī, called the reports mutawātir, “mass-transmitted”. Ibn Khaldūn, by contrast, examined the chains in his Muqaddima and judged nearly all of them open to criticism. Since the phrase “his father's name the name of my father” would make him Muḥammad b. ʿAbdullāh, Sunnis expect a Mahdī yet to be born. Shia scholars point out that the phrase is missing from many chains of the same hadith.
Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4282–4290 (Kitāb al-Mahdī) · Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2230–2231 · Sunan Ibn Mājah 4082–4088 · Ibn Khaldūn, al-Muqaddima 3 · al-Shawkānī, al-Tawḍīḥ (on the mass transmission of the reports about the Mahdī, the Dajjāl and the Messiah)
Sunni traditionSufism
Sunnis who accepted the twelfth Imam
A minority of Sunni scholars accepted that the Mahdī was the son of al-Ḥasan al-ʿAskarī, born and hidden. Among them were the Shāfiʿī Ibn Ṭalḥa (d. 1254), Sibṭ b. al-Jawzī (d. 1256), al-Ganjī al-Shāfiʿī (d. 1260), and later the Ḥanafī Sufi al-Qundūzī (d. 1877, or by another account 1853–54). The 16th-century Egyptian Sufi al-Shaʿrānī quotes Ibn ʿArabī's Meccan Revelations as saying the Mahdī is of the children of al-Ḥasan al-ʿAskarī. The passage is not in the printed editions of the Futūḥāt, whose chapter on the Mahdī's helpers (ch. 366) traces his descent from Fāṭima and ʿAlī but, as the text is usually read, does not name al-ʿAskarī. Whether al-Shaʿrānī had a different manuscript is debated.
Ibn Ṭalḥa, Maṭālib al-saʾūl · Sibṭ b. al-Jawzī, Tadhkirat al-khawāṣṣ · al-Ganjī, al-Bayān fī akhbār Ṣāḥib al-Zamān · al-Shaʿrānī, al-Yawāqīt wa-l-jawāhir · Ibn ʿArabī, al-Futūḥāt al-makkiyya, ch. 366
HistorySunni traditionShia tradition
Mahdīs in history
Many have claimed to be the Mahdī, or been proclaimed as such:
- ʿAbdullāh al-Mahdī, founder of the Ismāʿīlī Fāṭimid caliphate in North Africa in 909;
- Ibn Tūmart (d. 1130), founder of the Almohad movement in Morocco;
- Sayyid Muḥammad of Jaunpur (d. 1505), whose followers, the Mahdavīs, survive in India;
- Muḥammad Aḥmad of the Sudan, who rose in 1881 and took Khartoum in 1885;
- Mīrzā Ghulām Aḥmad (d. 1908), founder of the Aḥmadiyya, who claimed to be both the Mahdī and the promised Messiah;
- Muḥammad al-Qaḥṭānī, proclaimed Mahdī by Juhaymān al-ʿUtaybī's men when they seized the Grand Mosque of Mecca on 20 November 1979.
Sunni and Twelver scholars rejected each of these claims, though Ismāʿīlīs accepted the first.
W. Madelung, “al-Mahdī”, EI2 · P. M. Holt, The Mahdist State in the Sudan (2nd ed. 1970) · Y. Friedmann, Prophecy Continuous (1989)
Other Shia, and the Baháʼí faith
Shia traditionHistory
Zaydīs and Ismāʿīlīs
Not all Shia accept the twelfth Imam:
- The Zaydīs recognise no hidden Imam. They expect a Mahdī of the Prophet's family in general terms, and look to whatever learned descendant of al-Ḥasan or al-Ḥusayn rises in arms.
- The early Ismāʿīlīs held that Muḥammad b. Ismāʿīl, grandson of al-Ṣādiq, was the hidden Qāʾim who would return. In 899 their leadership instead declared a living line of Imams, and in 909 its head founded the Fāṭimid caliphate as al-Mahdī.
- The Nizārī Ismāʿīlīs today follow a living, present Imam, the Aga Khan.
- The Mustaʿlī Ismāʿīlīs, such as the Dāwūdī Bohras, hold that their twenty-first Imam, al-Ṭayyib, went into hiding in the 12th century. In his absence they are led by a Dāʿī.
F. Daftary, The Ismāʿīlīs (2nd ed. 2007) · al-Nawbakhtī, Firaq al-shīʿa
BaháʼíShia traditionHistory
The Báb and Baháʼuʼlláh
On the evening of 22 May 1844 (23 May by Baháʼí reckoning, which begins the day at sunset) in Shiraz, the young merchant Sayyid ʿAlī-Muḥammad declared himself the Báb, the “gate” to the hidden Imam. It was the year 1260 AH, a thousand lunar years after the Imam's disappearance in 260 AH. In 1848 he proclaimed that he was himself the Qāʾim, and announced a new revelation abrogating Islamic law. He was executed by firing squad in Tabriz in 1850, and thousands of his followers were killed. One of them, Mīrzā Ḥusayn-ʿAlī Nūrī, Baháʼuʼlláh, declared in 1863 that he was the one whom the Báb had foretold. His followers became the Baháʼí faith. Baháʼís hold that the Báb fulfilled the promise of the Qāʾim; they do not believe that the son of al-ʿAskarī lived on in hiding. Baháʼuʼlláh's Kitáb-i-Íqán interprets the Shia hadith of the Qāʾim to show that they were fulfilled in the Báb.
Baháʼuʼlláh, Kitáb-i-Íqán · D. MacEoin, The Messiah of Shiraz (2009) · Encyclopaedia Iranica, “Bāb, ʿAli-Moḥammad Širāzi”
Historians and the Occultation
History
How the doctrine took shape
Modern historians largely agree that the doctrine of the Twelfth Imam took its final form during the crisis after 874. Some, such as Hossein Modarressi and Etan Kohlberg, have shown how earlier hadith about a hidden Qāʾim, used before by the Kaysāniyya, the Wāqifa and others, were applied to the son of al-ʿAskarī. They also trace how the number twelve became fixed. Jassim Hussain traced the deputies' network, and Abdulaziz Sachedina studied the messianic theology. Mohammad Ali Amir-Moezzi has stressed its esoteric dimension. Believers regard the Occultation as a historical reality foretold by the earlier Imams. Historians cannot settle whether the boy existed, since the sources that speak of him are those of the believing community. That agents in Baghdad led much of the community in these decades is well attested, though some historians, such as Verena Klemm, argue that the list of exactly four deputies was settled only later.
H. Modarressi, Crisis and Consolidation (1993) · E. Kohlberg, “From Imāmiyya to Ithnā-ʿashariyya” (BSOAS 39, 1976) · J. M. Hussain, The Occultation of the Twelfth Imam (1982) · A. Sachedina, Islamic Messianism (1981) · V. Klemm, “Die vier sufarāʾ des Zwölften Imām” (Die Welt des Orients 15, 1984) · M. A. Amir-Moezzi, The Divine Guide in Early Shiʿism (1994)
Across the traditions
Author's note · comparing traditions
TalmudShia hadith
The Messiah at the gates of Rome
The Shia belief that the Imam is already in the world, seeing people who do not know him, has a close parallel in the Talmud. Rabbi Joshua ben Levi asks Elijah where the Messiah is, and is told he sits among the poor and the sick at the gate of Rome, binding his wounds one at a time, so as to be ready the moment he is called. Rabbi Joshua finds him and asks, “When will the master come?” He answers, “Today.” When the day passes, Elijah explains that he meant the verse “To day if ye will hear his voice” (Psalm 95:7; Sanhedrin 98a). In both traditions the saviour is hidden, not absent. In some teachings of both, his coming waits on the people's readiness.
Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 98a · Psalm 95:7 · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1
Author's note · comparing traditions
TalmudNew TestamentShia hadith
Do not calculate the end
All three traditions expect a final deliverer, and all three warn against fixing the date:
- The Talmud curses “those who calculate the end”, since when the date passes people say he will never come (Sanhedrin 97b).
- Jesus says that no one knows the day or the hour, “not the angels which are in heaven, neither the Son, but the Father” (Mark 13:32). He tells his disciples it is not for them to know the times (Acts 1:7).
- Al-Ṣādiq says “the time-setters lie”.
In each, the warning sits beside a long history of people setting dates anyway: Jewish messiahs such as Sabbatai Zevi in 1665, Christian predictions of the Second Coming, and Muslim expectations at the turn of the Islamic millennium.
Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 97b · Mark 13:32 · Acts 1:7 · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1
Author's note · comparing traditions
Jewish traditionNew TestamentZoroastrianShia traditionSunni hadith
Messiah, Second Coming, Saoshyant
Islamic eschatology joins the Mahdī with Jesus, who returns to kill the Antichrist (al-Dajjāl). In this it stands between the Jewish and Christian hopes:
- In Jewish belief the Messiah son of David, still to come, will gather the exiles and rebuild the Temple. Maimonides made belief in his coming the twelfth of his thirteen principles; the later creed Ani Maamin, based on them, says that “though he tarry”, the believer waits every day for him to come.
- Christians await the return of Jesus himself in glory (Acts 1:11; 1 Thessalonians 4:16).
- Zoroastrian tradition expects the Saoshyant, a saviour born at the end of time of Zoroaster's seed, preserved in a lake. He will raise the dead and renew the world (frashokereti).
Scholars have long debated how far these traditions influenced one another, especially in Iran, where Zoroastrian, Jewish, Christian and Muslim communities lived side by side. The Shia Mahdī shares something with each: he is a descendant of a prophet like the Messiah, returns like Christ, and renews the world like the Saoshyant.
Maimonides, Commentary on the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 10 (the Thirteen Principles) · Acts 1:11 · 1 Thessalonians 4:16 · Greater Bundahishn 33–34 (tr. Anklesaria) · M. Boyce, Zoroastrians (1979)
Author's note · comparing traditions
Hebrew BibleQurʾanChristian traditionShia tradition
The ones who did not die
Shia arguments for the Imam's long life draw on figures that several traditions believe never died. Enoch “walked with God: and he was not; for God took him” (Genesis 5:24). Elijah went up to heaven in a whirlwind (2 Kings 2:11), and Malachi promises he will return before the great day (4:5). Jews still set a cup for him at Passover and a chair at every circumcision. Muslims add al-Khiḍr, Moses' mysterious guide (Q 18:65–82), and with Christians hold that Jesus was taken up alive. Folk traditions of a hidden king who will return, such as the sleeping emperor in the mountain in Germany or King Sebastian of Portugal, show that the hope of a deliverer who did not die is not confined to scripture.
Genesis 5:24 · 2 Kings 2:11 · Malachi 4:5 · Qurʾan 18:65–82; 4:157–158 · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn