Dhū l-Kifl is one of the prophets named in the Qurʾan with no story attached. He appears twice, both times in a list: with Ishmael and Idrīs as men of patience, and with Ishmael and Elisha as among the best. His name means “the one of the kifl”, a word that can mean a portion, a double share or a pledge, and Muslim scholars never agreed who he was. Some said he was Job's son; some that he was the biblical prophet Ezekiel; others that he was Elijah, Joshua or Zechariah, or a righteous man who earned the name by a promise he kept. His shrines are just as varied: Ezekiel's tomb at al-Kifl in Iraq, venerated by Jews and Muslims, and a village shrine at Kifl Ḥāris in the West Bank that Jews identify with the burial places of Joshua and Caleb.
In the Qurʾan
Qurʾan
Two verses
“And (mention) Ishmael, and Idris, and Dhu'l-Kifl. All were of the steadfast. And We brought them in unto Our mercy. Lo! they are among the righteous” (21:85–86, Pickthall). “And remember Ishmael and al-Yasaʿ and Dhū l-Kifl: all are among the best” (38:48). The Qurʾan says nothing more about him. His placement among prophets led most scholars to count him one; a minority held that he was only a righteous man.
Qurʾan 21:85–86; 38:48
Tafsir
The name
Kifl can mean a share or portion, especially a double portion; a guarantee or pledge (from the same root as kafāla, “surety”); or a burden one takes on. Different explanations of the name match different identifications: the man who took on a duty and fulfilled it, the man who received a double share of reward, or a name derived from a place called al-Kifl.
al-Ṭabarī, Jāmiʿ al-bayān (on 21:85) · al-Rāghib al-Iṣfahānī, al-Mufradāt (k-f-l)
Who was he?
TafsirSunni tradition
The man of the pledge
The best-known explanation, reported by al-Ṭabarī from Mujāhid and others, tells of an aged prophet of Israel, often said to be al-Yasaʿ (Elisha), who sought a successor. He asked who would pledge to fast by day, pray by night and never grow angry. A young man pledged, and was appointed. Iblīs tried to provoke him by coming as an old man with a complaint during his midday rest, day after day, but he never lost his temper. He was named Dhū l-Kifl because he kept his pledge. Some reports say he was not a prophet but a righteous judge.
al-Ṭabarī, Jāmiʿ al-bayān (on 21:85) · Ibn Kathīr, Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyāʾ (Dhū l-Kifl)
Sunni tradition
Job's son
Wahb b. Munabbih, in a report preserved by al-Ḥākim, said that after Job's death God sent his son Bishr as a prophet and named him Dhū l-Kifl, and that he lived in Syria. On this view Dhū l-Kifl is a descendant of Isaac through Esau, which is why his card stands beside Isaac's in this tree.
al-Ḥākim, al-Mustadrak (report of Wahb b. Munabbih), via al-Suyūṭī, Muʿtarak al-aqrān · Ibn Kathīr, Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyāʾ (Dhū l-Kifl)
Sunni traditionShia tradition
Ezekiel, and other candidates
Many Muslim scholars and travellers identified Dhū l-Kifl with Ezekiel (Ḥizqīl), whose tomb stands at the village of al-Kifl in Iraq, between Najaf and Ḥilla. Others proposed Elijah, Joshua, Zechariah or Isaiah. A Shia hadith gives his real name as ʿUwaydiyā, sometimes equated with Obadiah. None of these identifications is supported by the Qurʾan itself, and al-Ṭabarī and Ibn Kathīr report several without settling the matter.
Ibn Kathīr, Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyāʾ (Dhū l-Kifl) · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār 13 · Encyclopaedia of Islam, 2nd ed., “Dhu ’l-Kifl”
Sunni hadith
A different “al-Kifl” in the hadith
Al-Tirmidhī reports a hadith about a man of the Children of Israel named al-Kifl, a notorious sinner, who, when a woman he had paid trembled and wept, saying that only need had driven her to it, let her go with the money, repented, and died that night, after which “God has forgiven al-Kifl” was found written on his door. Al-Tirmidhī graded it ḥasan; others consider it weak. Ibn Kathīr suggested that this al-Kifl, named without “Dhū”, was perhaps a different man.
Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2496 · Musnad Aḥmad (ḥadīth Ibn ʿUmar, al-Kifl)
History
A modern suggestion: the Buddha
In the 20th century some Muslim writers proposed that Dhū l-Kifl is the Buddha, reading “Kifl” as an Arabic form of Kapilavastu, the Buddha's home city, and pointing to the Qurʾan's statement that every people has had a messenger. The idea has had some currency in South Asia, but it rests mainly on the name (some supporters also read the fig of Sūra 95 as the Buddha's tree) and remains a minority view.
Wikipedia, “Gautama Buddha in world religions” · Qurʾan 35:24; 95:1
Shrines
HistoryJewish traditionSunni traditionShia tradition
Ezekiel's tomb at al-Kifl
The tomb at al-Kifl, near the Euphrates south of Ḥilla, has been venerated as Ezekiel's for many centuries. The 12th-century Jewish traveller Benjamin of Tudela described large Jewish pilgrimages to it, and it remained a Jewish pilgrimage site, with Hebrew inscriptions inside, until the departure of most of Iraq's Jews in 1950–51. Muslims honour it as the tomb of the prophet Ḥizqīl, or of Dhū l-Kifl; its minaret dates from the Ilkhanid period in the 14th century. It is now in a mainly Shia area and is maintained as a Muslim shrine.
Benjamin of Tudela, Travels · Encyclopaedia of Islam, 2nd ed., “al-Kifl”
HistoryJewish traditionSunni tradition
Kifl Ḥāris
The Palestinian village of Kifl Ḥāris, near Salfit in the West Bank, contains shrines that local Muslims attribute to Dhū l-Kifl and to other prophets. Jewish tradition identifies the village with Timnath-heres (or Timnath-serah), where the Book of Joshua says Joshua was buried (Joshua 24:30), and venerates tombs there as those of Joshua, his father Nun and Caleb. Jewish pilgrims visit, under Israeli military escort, especially on the anniversary of Joshua's death.
Joshua 19:50; 24:30 · Judges 2:9 · Wikipedia, “Kifl Haris”
Across the traditions
Author's note · comparing traditions
QurʾanHebrew BibleNew Testament
A name without a story
Dhū l-Kifl belongs with the figures whom scripture names but barely describes, and whom later tradition supplied with lives. The Qurʾan pairs him with Idrīs, whom Muslims identify with Enoch, of whom Genesis says only that he “walked with God” and was taken (5:24). The Bible has Melchizedek, who appears in three verses of Genesis and becomes, in Psalms, Hebrews and the Dead Sea Scrolls, a priest for ever. In each case the silence of the text invited identifications: Muslims matched Dhū l-Kifl with known biblical prophets, as Jews and Christians identified Melchizedek with Shem or with a heavenly figure.
Qurʾan 19:56–57; 21:85 · Genesis 5:24; 14:18–20 · Psalm 110:4 · Hebrews 7
Author's note · comparing traditions
Jewish traditionSunni traditionShia tradition
One shrine, several prophets
The two shrines of Dhū l-Kifl show how holy places have been shared and renamed across traditions. At al-Kifl, Jews prayed for centuries at a tomb that Muslims also honoured, under a Hebrew-inscribed dome and an Islamic minaret. At Kifl Ḥāris, the same tombs are those of Joshua, Nun and Caleb for Jewish pilgrims and of Dhū l-Kifl and other prophets for the villagers. In both, a name in the Qurʾan without a story has been attached to a prophet with a biblical one, and the two communities' memories of the place have overlapped.
Benjamin of Tudela, Travels · Joshua 24:30 · Encyclopaedia of Islam, 2nd ed., “Dhu ’l-Kifl”