Enoch gets four verses in Genesis and ends them without dying: he “walked with God, and he was not, for God took him”. Those few words grew into one of the largest bodies of legend attached to anyone in this tree. Jewish apocalyptic writers made him a heavenly scribe and the seer of the books of Enoch, and later Jewish mystics made him the angel Metatron. Christians counted him with Elijah as the two who never died, and expected both to return at the end of time. Muslims honour him as the prophet Idrīs, the first to write with the pen and to sew clothes, whom God “raised to a high place”. Many medieval scholars, Muslim and otherwise, identified him with Hermes, the father of philosophy, and Latter-day Saints remember the holy city he built, which was taken up with him.
In Genesis
Hebrew Bible
Four verses
Enoch was born when his father Jared was 162. At 65 he fathered Methuselah. After that he “walked with God” for 300 years and had other sons and daughters. He lived 365 years in all, and then “he was not, for God took him”. Of the ten men in Genesis 5, Enoch is the only one whose entry ends without his death. (Noah's death is held back until Genesis 9:29.)
Genesis 5:18–24; 9:29
Hebrew Bible
“Walked with God”
The Hebrew phrase is used of only one other person, Noah (Genesis 6:9), Enoch's great-grandson. The Greek Septuagint did not translate it word for word: it says Enoch “was well-pleasing to God”, and that “he was not found, because God had translated him”. The Letter to the Hebrews quotes this Greek wording.
Genesis 5:22, 24; 6:9 · Septuagint, Genesis 5:24 · Hebrews 11:5
Hebrew BibleNew TestamentPseudepigrapha
The seventh from Adam
Counting Adam as the first, Enoch is the seventh generation. Ancient writers made much of this. The Letter of Jude and the Book of Enoch both call him “the seventh from Adam”, and seven is the number of completion throughout the Bible.
1 Chronicles 1:1–3 · Jude 14 · 1 Enoch 60:8; 93:3
Hebrew Bible
Gone before his elders
If you work through the ages given in Genesis 5, Enoch was 308 when Adam died. He was taken 57 years later, in year 987 after Creation. Seth, Enosh, Kenan, Mahalalel and his father Jared were all still alive, so he was the first of Adam's line to leave the earth after Adam himself. His son Methuselah went on to live longer than anyone else in the Bible.
Genesis 5 (arithmetic of the ages given) · Ussher, Annales (AM 622–987)
Hebrew Bible
The other Enoch
Genesis has a second Enoch: Cain's son, after whom Cain named the first city (Genesis 4:17). The two lists of descendants, Cain's and Seth's, share several similar names: Enoch, Lamech, and the near-matches Irad and Jared, and Methushael and Methuselah. Ancient readers took care to tell the two Enochs apart, and Jude's “seventh from Adam” may be part of that.
Genesis 4:17–18; 5:18–25
The books of Enoch
Pseudepigrapha
1 Enoch: five books in one
The work known as 1 Enoch is a collection of five Jewish writings from different centuries, all told in Enoch's voice:
- The Book of the Watchers (chapters 1–36)
- The Parables or Similitudes (37–71)
- The Astronomical Book (72–82)
- The Dream Visions, which include the Animal Apocalypse (83–90)
- The Epistle of Enoch (91–108)
The Astronomical Book and the Book of the Watchers are usually dated to the third century BCE. That makes them among the oldest Jewish writings that are not in the Hebrew Bible.
G. W. E. Nickelsburg, 1 Enoch 1 (Hermeneia, 2001) · P. F. Esler, “Taking 1 Enoch Seriously” (Bible and Interpretation, 2018)
Pseudepigrapha
The Watchers
The Book of the Watchers expands on the brief story in Genesis 6 of the “sons of God” who took human wives. Two hundred angels, the Watchers, led by Shemihazah, swear an oath on Mount Hermon and come down to earth. They father giants, and they teach humans forbidden arts. Asael teaches metalworking, weapons and cosmetics; others teach spells and the signs of the stars. The fallen angels ask Enoch, called “the scribe of righteousness”, to plead for them before God. He does so and is shown in a vision that their plea is refused. The Flood is the answer to the evil they caused.
1 Enoch 6–16 · Genesis 6:1–4
Pseudepigrapha
A calendar of 364 days
In the Astronomical Book, the angel Uriel shows Enoch the movements of the sun, moon and stars. The year it teaches is exactly 364 days, which is 52 weeks, so festivals always fall on the same day of the week. The same calendar is defended in Jubilees and in some of the Dead Sea Scrolls, and it appears to have divided Jewish groups of the time from the Temple's calendar.
1 Enoch 72–82 · Jubilees 6:32–38
Pseudepigrapha
“That Son of Man”
The Parables describe a heavenly figure, the Chosen One or the Son of Man, who sits on a throne of glory and judges kings. At the end, Enoch himself is told that he is that Son of Man, although translators and interpreters disagree about how to read the line. The Parables are the only part of 1 Enoch not found among the Dead Sea Scrolls. Most scholars date them to around the turn of the era, close to the time when the Gospels used “Son of Man” for Jesus.
1 Enoch 46–48; 71:14 · Nickelsburg & VanderKam, 1 Enoch 2 (Hermeneia, 2012)
Pseudepigrapha
History told with animals
In the Animal Apocalypse, the whole of history from Adam to the Maccabean wars is told as a fable. The patriarchs are white bulls, Israel is a flock of sheep, the nations are wild beasts and birds of prey, and the Watchers are falling stars. A white bull at the end, in whom all creatures are transformed, stands for a new beginning for humanity.
1 Enoch 85–90
Christian traditionHistory
Found in Ethiopia, confirmed at Qumran
For more than a thousand years, Europe knew the Book of Enoch only through quotations, chiefly in the Byzantine chronicler George Syncellus. In 1773 the Scottish traveller James Bruce brought Geʿez (classical Ethiopic) copies back from Ethiopia. The Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church had kept the whole book in its Bible all along, and it still does, along with Jubilees. A Greek manuscript of the first 32 chapters turned up at Akhmim in Egypt in the 1880s. Then the caves at Qumran produced Aramaic fragments of about a dozen copies, covering every part except the Parables. This convinced most scholars that most of the book was first written in Aramaic.
J. T. Milik, The Books of Enoch: Aramaic Fragments of Qumrân Cave 4 (1976) · Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo canon
Pseudepigrapha
2 Enoch: the 366 books
A second book, preserved almost entirely in Old Church Slavonic (a few Coptic fragments were identified in 2009), has two angels carry Enoch through the heavens to the face of God. There he writes down everything he is told, in 366 books (the count varies between manuscripts). He comes back to earth for thirty days to teach his sons before he is taken for good. The book ends with a strange story of the miraculous birth of Melchizedek, Noah's nephew. Its date and origin are still disputed; many scholars place it in the first century CE.
2 Enoch 1–23; 36; 71–72 · F. I. Andersen, “2 Enoch”, in Charlesworth (ed.), Old Testament Pseudepigrapha 1 (1983)
Pseudepigrapha
First to write, in Jubilees
The Book of Jubilees, written in the second century BCE, calls Enoch the first human being to learn writing, knowledge and wisdom. He writes down the signs of heaven so that people can know the seasons, and he marries Edni (Edna in Charles's translation), daughter of Danel. He then spends six jubilees of years with the angels. Finally he is placed in the Garden of Eden, where he writes the judgement of the world. Because of him, in James VanderKam's translation, the waters of the Flood did not come on the land of Eden. R. H. Charles read the verse the opposite way, as saying the Flood did cover Eden.
Jubilees 4:17–25; 10:17 · J. C. VanderKam, Jubilees (Hermeneia, 2018) · R. H. Charles, The Book of Jubilees (1913)
PseudepigraphaManichaean
The Book of Giants
A further Enoch story, the Book of Giants, follows the Watchers' sons as they dream of their own destruction and send to Enoch to explain the dreams. Aramaic copies were found at Qumran. The book also had a second life: the prophet Mani adopted it in the third century CE, and fragments in Middle Persian, Sogdian and Uyghur were found at Turfan in Central Asia.
4Q203, 4Q530–532 (Qumran) · W. B. Henning, “The Book of the Giants” (BSOAS 11, 1943)
In Christian tradition
New TestamentPseudepigrapha
A New Testament quotation
The Letter of Jude quotes “Enoch also, the seventh from Adam”, who prophesied that “the Lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints” to judge the ungodly. The quotation is from 1 Enoch 1:9. It is the clearest case of a New Testament writer citing a book outside the Hebrew Bible as prophecy. It is also why Jude itself was doubted by some in the early Church.
Jude 14–15 · 1 Enoch 1:9 · Jerome, De viris illustribus 4
New Testament
An example of faith
Hebrews names Enoch among its heroes of faith. Before he was taken, he received the testimony that he had pleased God, and “without faith it is impossible to please him”. Luke's genealogy of Jesus also passes through him.
Hebrews 11:5–6 · Luke 3:37
Church Fathers
Scripture or not?
The early Church was divided over the Book of Enoch. Tertullian defended it as genuine scripture. Some, he said, rejected it because they doubted it could have survived the Flood, but Noah, Enoch's great-grandson, could have preserved it. Augustine accepted that Enoch wrote some things by divine inspiration. Even so, he held that the books under his name were rightly kept out of the canon, because they were so old that their authenticity could not be proved. The Latin and Greek churches both eventually left it out; the Ethiopian church did not.
Tertullian, De cultu feminarum 1.3 · Augustine, City of God 15.23; 18.38
Church FathersChristian tradition
The two witnesses
Revelation 11 tells of two witnesses who will prophesy in the last days, be killed by the beast, and rise again after three and a half days. The earliest interpretation names them as Enoch and Elijah, the only two people Scripture says did not die. Hippolytus of Rome, in the early 3rd century, is among the first writers to state this plainly. Tertullian gives the reason: their death was not cancelled but postponed, so that by their blood they would destroy the Antichrist.
Revelation 11:3–12 · Hippolytus, On Christ and Antichrist 43 · Tertullian, De anima 50
Christian tradition
Waiting at the gate of Paradise
In the Gospel of Nicodemus, Christ leads Adam and the righteous out of Hades into Paradise. At the gate they meet two old men. The men explain that they are Enoch and Elijah, taken there alive. They are waiting to return at the end of time to fight the Antichrist, be killed, and be raised after three and a half days. The scene was repeated in medieval preaching and mystery plays across Europe.
Gospel of Nicodemus (Descent into Hell) 25
Christian tradition
Honoured as a forefather
Eastern churches remember Enoch among the righteous forefathers of Christ on the Sunday of the Holy Forefathers before Christmas. The Armenian Apostolic Church also includes him among the Holy Forefathers in its calendar of saints.
Byzantine Menaion, Sunday of the Holy Forefathers · Armenian Church calendar
In Jewish tradition
Apocrypha
Praise in the Wisdom books
Ben Sira, writing around 180 BCE, praises Enoch twice. Once it calls him “a sign of knowledge” for all generations (the Greek translation has “an example of repentance”). Once it says no one on earth was created like him, “for he was taken up from the earth”. The Wisdom of Solomon does not name him but is generally read as speaking of him: a righteous man who “was caught up so that evil might not change his understanding”, because he was perfected in a short time.
Ben Sira 44:16; 49:14 · Wisdom of Solomon 4:10–14
Jewish tradition
A model of repentance
Philo of Alexandria, the first-century Jewish philosopher, read Enoch as a man who changed from a worse life to a better one. For Philo, being “translated” meant moving from one way of living to another, and “not being found” meant withdrawing from the crowd into a solitary life.
Philo, De Abrahamo 17–26
Midrash
Rabbinic caution
Some sages in Genesis Rabbah were noticeably cool toward Enoch. Rabbi Ḥama bar Hoshaya says he was entered in the register of the wicked. Rabbi Aibu says he was a hypocrite (ḥanef), sometimes righteous and sometimes wicked, so God removed him while he was righteous. When heretics (apikorsim) argued from Genesis that Enoch never died, Rabbi Abbahu replied that “taking” in the Bible can mean death, citing Ezekiel 24:16. Many scholars see this as a reaction to the high claims other groups were making about Enoch.
Genesis Rabbah 25:1 · A. Y. Reed, Fallen Angels and the History of Judaism and Christianity (2005)
Jewish tradition
Rashi's reading
Rashi, the great 11th-century commentator, follows the cautious line. Enoch was righteous but easily swayed to turn wicked, so God hurried to make him die before his time. That, Rashi says, is why the verse says “he was not”: he did not live out his years.
Rashi on Genesis 5:24
Targum
Metatron, the Great Scribe
One Aramaic translation of the Torah goes the other way. Targum Pseudo-Jonathan renders Genesis 5:24 as saying Enoch served before the Lord in truth and ascended to the firmament by the word of the Lord. His name was called Metatron, the Great Scribe. Here the patriarch has become a heavenly scribe and angel.
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Genesis 5:24
Talmud
“Two powers in heaven”
The Talmud tells of four sages who entered the “orchard” of mystical speculation. One of them, Elisha ben Abuya, saw Metatron seated in heaven, writing down the merits of Israel. Since only God sits in heaven, he concluded “perhaps there are two powers”, and he abandoned the faith, after which he was known only as Aḥer, “the Other”. To correct the error, Metatron was struck with sixty lashes of fire. Metatron appears only three times in the Babylonian Talmud, and the Talmud never says he was Enoch.
Babylonian Talmud, Ḥagigah 14b–15a; Sanhedrin 38b; Avodah Zarah 3b
Jewish tradition
3 Enoch: “the lesser YHWH”
The fullest early account of Enoch as Metatron is 3 Enoch, also called Sefer Hekhalot, a work of Jewish mysticism usually dated to late antiquity or after. (The date of Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, which also makes the identification, is debated.) Rabbi Ishmael ascends to the seventh heaven and meets Metatron, who reveals that he is Enoch son of Jared. God took him up as a witness against the generation of the Flood. His flesh was turned to flame, he was given 72 wings and a throne, and he was called “the lesser YHWH”. Gershom Scholem argued that two traditions merged here: one of a Michael-like chief angel, also called Yahoel, and one of the translated Enoch.
3 Enoch 3–16 · G. Scholem, “Metatron”, Encyclopaedia Judaica · G. Scholem, Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism (1941), lecture 2
Jewish tradition
Among those who entered Paradise alive
A rabbinic list names nine people who entered the Garden of Eden while still alive. Enoch son of Jared comes first, followed by Elijah, the Messiah, Eliezer the servant of Abraham, Hiram king of Tyre, Ebed-melech the Cushite, Jabez, Bithiah daughter of Pharaoh, and Serah daughter of Asher. Some versions add Rabbi Joshua ben Levi.
Derekh Eretz Zuta 1
Midrash
The secret of the calendar
In Pirkei de-Rabbi Eliezer, the secret of intercalation, the method of keeping the lunar calendar in step with the sun, was handed down from Adam to Enoch, who passed it to Noah. Like the Astronomical Book, this tradition makes Enoch a keeper of time, here in a rabbinic setting.
Pirkei de-Rabbi Eliezer 8
Jewish tradition
King Enoch and the fiery horses
Sefer ha-Yashar, a Hebrew retelling of Genesis probably written in early 16th-century Italy (its earliest surviving printing is Venice, 1625), tells a longer story. Enoch withdrew from the world to serve God in seclusion, and when he came out the people made him king. He ruled and taught them for many years. In the end he rode up to heaven in a whirlwind, with horses and chariots of fire, as Elijah later would. Some of his followers refused to turn back. When the kings came looking for them, they found only deep snow and no trace of the men.
Sefer ha-Yashar 3:36–38
Kabbalah
Enoch the cobbler
A Kabbalistic tradition makes Enoch a shoemaker. With every stitch he joined the upper to the lower, uniting the worlds above with the world below, and so drew blessing down. The 13th–14th-century Kabbalist Isaac of Acre recorded the story in the name of his teacher, Judah ha-Darshan Ashkenazi. Later retellings speak of uniting the Holy One with the Shekhinah, the divine presence, and Hasidic teachers made it a model for serving God through ordinary work. Separately, the Zohar cites a “Book of Enoch” as an ancient book of wisdom.
Isaac of Acre, Meʾirat ʿEinayim · M. Idel, Enoch: From Patriarch to Angel (in The Angelic World, 2008) · Zohar I:37b
Idrīs in Islam
Qurʾan
“A truthful one and a prophet”
The Qurʾan mentions Idrīs twice. In Sūrat Maryam he is “a man of truth (ṣiddīq) and a prophet”, and God says “We raised him to a high place”. In Sūrat al-Anbiyāʾ he is listed with Ishmael and Dhū al-Kifl among the patient, whom God admitted to His mercy. The Qurʾan gives no other details, and it never names his father or links him to Enoch.
Qurʾan 19:56–57; 21:85–86
Sunni traditionShia tradition
Idrīs is Akhnūkh
Early Muslim historians identify Idrīs with the biblical Enoch, whom they call Akhnūkh son of Yārid. Ibn Isḥāq, in the genealogy at the start of his biography of the Prophet, gives Akhnūkh as an ancestor of Muhammad. He adds that “he is the prophet Idrīs, as they claim, and God knows best”, the first of Adam's descendants to be given prophethood and to write with the pen. The identification soon became the standard view.
Ibn Hishām, al-Sīra al-Nabawiyya (genealogy) · al-Ṭabarī, Tārīkh 1
TafsirShia hadith
Why “Idrīs”?
Many commentators explain the name from the Arabic darasa, “to study”, because he studied and taught the scriptures so much. A report attributed to Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq, in the Tafsīr of al-Qummī, says the same. Others, such as al-Zamakhsharī and al-Bayḍāwī, report this view but reject it on grammatical grounds: the name does not take full Arabic case endings, which shows it is foreign.
al-Qurṭubī, al-Jāmiʿ on 19:56 · Tafsīr al-Qummī on 19:56 · al-Zamakhsharī, al-Kashshāf and al-Bayḍāwī, Anwār al-tanzīl on 19:56
Sunni traditionTafsir
First with the pen, the needle and the stars
Ibn Isḥāq calls Idrīs the first to write with the pen. Later commentators such as al-Thaʿlabī and al-Qurṭubī add more firsts:
- the first to write with the pen
- the first to cut cloth and sew garments (before him, people wore animal skins)
- the first to study the stars and their calculations
Ibn Kathīr notes that many scholars call Idrīs Hermes, “Hermes of the Hermeses”, but adds that they tell many falsehoods about him.
Ibn Kathīr, al-Bidāya wa-l-nihāya 1 (Idrīs) · al-Qurṭubī, al-Jāmiʿ li-aḥkām al-Qurʾān on 19:56
Sunni hadith
Thirty scrolls
A long hadith attributed to Abū Dharr counts the scriptures God sent down: 50 scrolls to Seth, 30 to Akhnūkh (Idrīs), 10 to Abraham, 10 to Moses before the Torah, and then the Torah, the Gospel, the Psalms and the Qurʾan. It also lists four “Syriac” prophets: Adam, Seth, Akhnūkh, “the first to write with the pen”, and Noah. Hadith critics grade it very weak (ḍaʿīf jiddan), because one of its narrators, Ibrāhīm ibn Hishām al-Ghassānī, was accused of lying.
Ṣaḥīḥ Ibn Ḥibbān 361 (Abū Dharr), with the gradings of al-Albānī and al-Arnaʾūṭ
Sunni hadith
The fourth heaven
In the account of the Prophet's Night Journey and Ascension in Bukhārī and Muslim, the Prophet meets a different prophet in each heaven. Idrīs is in the fourth. Commentators connect this with the Qurʾanic “high place”. Adam and Abraham greet Muhammad as “righteous son”, but Idrīs, like Moses and Jesus, says “welcome, righteous brother and righteous prophet”.
Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 349, 3207, 3887 · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 162
Sunni hadithSufism
Brother, not father?
Because Idrīs says “brother” rather than “son”, some scholars doubted that he was Muhammad's ancestor Enoch. Bukhārī shows both views. His chapter on Idrīs calls him Noah's great-grandfather, “or it is said, his grandfather”. His chapter on Ilyās (Elijah) records a report from Ibn Masʿūd and Ibn ʿAbbās that Ilyās is Idrīs. The mystic Ibn ʿArabī took the identification seriously. His Fuṣūṣ al-ḥikam has a chapter for each, the wisdom of holiness for Idrīs and the wisdom of intimacy for Ilyās, and the second opens by calling Ilyās the same person as Idrīs, who was raised to heaven and sent down again. Most scholars kept the identification with Enoch. Ibn Kathīr answers the “brother” argument directly: the narrator may not have kept the exact wording, or Idrīs spoke out of humility and courtesy.
Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, Kitāb aḥādīth al-anbiyāʾ (chapters on Idrīs and on Ilyās) · Ibn ʿArabī, Fuṣūṣ al-ḥikam, chs. 4 and 22 · Ibn Kathīr, al-Bidāya wa-l-nihāya 1
TafsirSunni tradition
Idrīs and the Angel of Death
A popular story is attributed to Kaʿb al-Aḥbār, a Yemeni Jewish convert to Islam in the time of the caliph ʿUmar. An angel befriended Idrīs because of his great good deeds, and Idrīs asked him to speak to the Angel of Death so that his life might be extended. The angel carried Idrīs on his wings up to the fourth heaven, where they met the Angel of Death coming down. He was astonished. He had been ordered to take Idrīs's soul in the fourth heaven, and had wondered how he could, since Idrīs was on earth. He took it there and then. Al-Ṭabarī reports the story in his commentary. Ibn Kathīr counts it among the Isrāʾīliyyāt, stories from Jewish and Christian lore, some of which he found objectionable.
al-Ṭabarī, Jāmiʿ al-bayān on 19:57 · Ibn Kathīr, Tafsīr on 19:57
Shia hadith
An heir in the chain
Shia tradition sees the prophets and their designated heirs (waṣīs) as one unbroken chain of divine guidance from Adam to the Twelfth Imam. Idrīs is a link in that chain, between Seth's line and Noah. The work Ithbāt al-waṣiyya, attributed to al-Masʿūdī, follows the chain heir by heir.
Ithbāt al-waṣiyya (attr. al-Masʿūdī) · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn, bāb 22
Shia hadith
The first occultation
Shaykh al-Ṣadūq's Kamāl al-dīn, the classic Shia book on the hidden Twelfth Imam, opens its stories of earlier prophets with the occultation (ghayba) of Idrīs. A tyrant king coveted the land of a believer. At the queen's urging he had the man killed and seized it. Idrīs brought God's message of doom. When the queen sent forty men to kill him, he went into hiding in a cave, where an angel brought him food. The king was killed, his kingdom destroyed, and dogs ate the queen's flesh. Idrīs refused to pray for rain for his people, and for twenty years none fell, while the next tyrant persecuted his followers, until the people repented. When Idrīs returned, he promised his followers that relief would come through one of his descendants, Noah, and then God raised him up. Al-Ṣadūq tells the story as a precedent: a long hidden period, a persecuted community, and a promised deliverer.
al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn wa-tamām al-niʿma, ch. 1 (ghaybat Idrīs)
Shia hadithShia tradition
His house in Kufa
According to reports from Imam al-Ṣādiq in al-Kāfī, the Masjid al-Sahla in Kufa was the house of Idrīs, where he did his sewing. The same mosque is linked with Abraham and with al-Khiḍr. Shia tradition also says the Mahdī will live there with his family after his return.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 3, Kitāb al-ṣalāt, bāb masjid al-Sahla · WikiShia, “Al-Sahla Mosque”
Hermes and the first philosopher
HistorySunni tradition
The three Hermeses
The 9th-century Baghdad astrologer Abū Maʿshar described three sages called Hermes. The first lived before the Flood and was the one the Hebrews call Enoch and the Arabs call Idrīs. Fearing the coming destruction, he built the pyramids and temples of Upper Egypt and carved all the sciences on their walls so they would survive. The second Hermes lived in Babylon after the Flood, and the third, in Egypt, wrote on alchemy. The story spread widely through Arabic and then Latin writing.
K. van Bladel, The Arabic Hermes (2009), ch. 4 · Ibn Juljul, Ṭabaqāt al-aṭibbāʾ
HistoryHermetic
Prophet of the Sabians
The pagan Sabians of Harran, who survived into the Islamic period, named Hermes, along with Agathodaimon, as one of their prophets. Muslim writers on religions, such as al-Shahrastānī, recorded this. It strengthened the link between Hermes, Idrīs and the ancient sciences.
al-Shahrastānī, al-Milal wa-l-niḥal · K. van Bladel, The Arabic Hermes (2009)
Baháʼí
“The first person who devoted himself to philosophy”
In one of his tablets, Baháʼu'lláh, the founder of the Baháʼí Faith, writes that the first person to devote himself to philosophy was Idrīs. Some called him Hermes, he adds, and he has a special name in every language. The editors of the Tablet of Wisdom (Lawḥ-i-Ḥikmat) quote this passage in their notes to it. The notes also quote him tracing the wisdom of the later sage Balīnūs (Apollonius) back to the Hermetic writings.
Baháʼu'lláh, quoted in the notes to the Lawḥ-i-Ḥikmat, Tablets of Baháʼu'lláh (bahai.org)
Manichaean
Mani's forerunners
Mani, the third-century founder of Manichaeism, presented himself as the last in a line of messengers. The Cologne Mani Codex quotes revelations said to have been given to Adam, Sethel, Enosh, Shem and Enoch, as proof that each true apostle wrote down what he saw in heaven.
Cologne Mani Codex
In Latter-day Saint scripture
Latter-day Saints
The City of Zion
The Book of Moses, part of the Latter-day Saint scripture the Pearl of Great Price, gives Enoch two long chapters. A reluctant young prophet, slow of speech, he becomes a preacher so powerful that the earth trembles and rivers turn from their course. He gathers a people called Zion, “of one heart and one mind”, with “no poor among them”. In the end the whole city is taken up into heaven, and the saying goes out that “Zion is fled”. Latter-day Saints look for its return at the end of time.
Moses 6:26–7:69 (Pearl of Great Price) · A. P. Schade & M. L. Bowen, The Book of Moses (BYU RSC, 2021), ch. on Moses 7
Latter-day Saints
The God who weeps
In a striking vision, Enoch sees God weep over the wickedness of humanity. He asks how the God of heaven, who is holy and eternal, can weep. God answers that his tears are for his own children, who hate one another and choose suffering. Latter-day Saint writers often point to this passage for its picture of a God who feels.
Moses 7:28–40
Latter-day Saints
430 years
Latter-day Saint scripture also says Adam ordained Enoch at 25 and blessed him at 65. It keeps the 365 years of Genesis but counts them differently: Enoch walked with God for 365 years after he was 65, so he was 430 when he was taken. The Book of Moses also gives Zion 365 years before it was taken up.
Doctrine and Covenants 107:48–49 · Moses 7:68; 8:1
History and scholarship
History
The name
The Hebrew Ḥanokh comes from a root meaning to dedicate or initiate, the same root as Hanukkah, the festival of the Temple's rededication. Western scholars have offered several other origins for the Arabic Idrīs, but none has won general agreement.
Brown–Driver–Briggs Hebrew Lexicon, ḥ-n-k
History
Enmeduranki of Sippar
Mesopotamian king lists name kings who ruled before the Flood. In several versions, the seventh is Enmeduranki (or Enmeduranna) of Sippar, the city of the sun god Shamash, credited with a reign of 21,000 years. A Babylonian text says Shamash and Adad brought him into their assembly and taught him the secrets of divination, which he passed on to the diviners. Many scholars, notably James VanderKam, have seen in him a model for Enoch: also seventh, also given heavenly secrets, and given 365 years, the number of days in the sun's year. Others are more cautious, and Seth Sanders has called parts of the case “academic folklore”.
W. G. Lambert, “Enmeduranki and Related Matters” (JCS 21, 1967) · J. C. VanderKam, Enoch and the Growth of an Apocalyptic Tradition (1984) · S. L. Sanders, “Enoch's Imaginary Ancestor: From Ancient Babylonian Scholarship to Modern Academic Folklore”, JAJ 9.2 (2018), 155–177
History
The sage who ascended
Mesopotamian tradition also tells of seven wise sages (apkallū) who brought civilisation before the Flood. A Babylonian ritual text says the seventh of them, Utuabzu, “ascended to heaven”. The Assyriologist Rykle Borger saw in this a close parallel to Enoch's ascent, and later scholars such as Amar Annus have built on his comparison.
R. Borger, “Die Beschwörungsserie bīt mēseri und die Himmelfahrt Henochs” (JNES 33, 1974) · A. Annus, “On the Origin of Watchers” (JSP 19.4, 2010)
Across the traditions
Author's note · comparing traditions
Shia hadithKabbalah
The tailor and the cobbler
Two traditions both give this antediluvian visionary a needle. In the Shia reports he sews in his house in Kufa, and in the general Muslim histories he is the first to make clothes. In Kabbalah he is a cobbler who unites heaven and earth with each stitch. Neither tradition needs the craft to explain him, and both treat it as part of his holiness: the man who walked with God or was raised to a high place did it while working with his hands. Scholars disagree about how the two are related. Michael Schneider has argued for an Islamic background to the cobbler story, and Moshe Idel for a lost Ashkenazi Jewish tradition about Enoch. The question is still open.
al-Kāfī 3 (Masjid al-Sahla) · M. Schneider, “Enoch, a Mystical Cobbler and Islamic Tradition” (Kabbalah 6, 2001) · M. Idel, The Angelic World (2008)
Author's note · comparing traditions
PseudepigraphaTargumSunni traditionBaháʼí
Everyone's first scribe
Almost every tradition that remembers Enoch gives him a pen:
- Jubilees makes him the first to learn writing.
- 1 Enoch calls him the scribe of righteousness, and 2 Enoch has him write hundreds of books in heaven.
- Targum Pseudo-Jonathan names him Metatron the Great Scribe.
- Muslim historians make Idrīs the first to write with the pen.
- The Hermes tradition makes him the father of the sciences, and a tablet of Baháʼu'lláh calls him the first philosopher.
Genesis itself says nothing about writing. One way to see this is that his short life and mysterious end left a space that each culture filled with its own highest ideal of learning.
Jubilees 4:17 · 1 Enoch 12:4 · Targum Pseudo-Jonathan Gen 5:24 · Ibn Hishām, al-Sīra · Tablets of Baháʼu'lláh, notes to the Lawḥ-i-Ḥikmat
Author's note · comparing traditions
Hebrew BibleMidrashChurch FathersTafsir
Did he die?
Genesis leaves it open, and many readers have tried to settle it.
- Hebrews says plainly that Enoch did not see death.
- Rabbi Abbahu, in Genesis Rabbah, answered heretics that “taking” means dying.
- Jewish mystics later went the furthest of all, turning him into an angel.
- The Church Fathers kept him alive but promised he would die at the end, as one of the two witnesses.
- Muslim exegetes are divided. In Kaʿb's story, Idrīs is raised alive and then dies in the fourth heaven, but many commentators hold that he lives on in heaven or in Paradise.
In most of these readings, Enoch is lifted up but still kept within limits. Muslim commentators themselves compared the question with the raising of Jesus, the other prophet the Qurʾan describes as raised by God.
Hebrews 11:5 · Genesis Rabbah 25:1 · Tertullian, De anima 50 · al-Ṭabarī on 19:57
Author's note · comparing traditions
Shia hadithSunni hadithChristian traditionJewish tradition
Enoch, Elijah and the hidden one
Enoch keeps being paired with Elijah. Both are taken alive. Christians make them the two witnesses of the last days. Bukhārī preserves a view that Ilyās is Idrīs, and Ibn ʿArabī builds on it. Al-Ṣadūq's story of Idrīs's occultation strikingly resembles Elijah's career in 1 Kings, though the order differs. There, Elijah declares a drought and hides by a brook, where ravens feed him (ch. 17). Later Ahab seizes Naboth's vineyard at Jezebel's urging, and Elijah foretells that dogs will eat Jezebel (ch. 21). In Judaism, Elijah is the one who will return before the Messiah. In Shia thought, the hidden Idrīs who returns to promise a deliverer is the first model for the hidden Imam. One way to read this: across these traditions, the man who leaves without dying becomes a figure through whom believers imagine waiting for redemption.
Kamāl al-dīn, ch. 1 · 1 Kings 17–21; 2 Kings 2:11; 9:36 · Malachi 3:23 (4:5 in English Bibles) · Revelation 11
Author's note · comparing traditions
Hebrew BiblePseudepigraphaHistory
365 or 364?
Genesis gives Enoch 365 years, the length of the solar year, which is one reason scholars connect him with the sun-city of Sippar. The Astronomical Book, written in his name, teaches a 364-day year. Latter-day Saint scripture keeps 365 but gives it to the years of Zion and to Enoch's walk with God. The number became a symbol, and each community read in it the calendar or the meaning it cared about.
Genesis 5:23 · 1 Enoch 72–82 · D&C 107:49 · Moses 7:68