Each of the three traditions waits for someone who will come at the end and set the world right. Judaism awaits the Messiah, a king of David's line still to come, and reads Malachi's promise of Elijah as his herald; Christianity awaits the return of “this same Jesus” who was taken up (Acts 1:11); Islam awaits the descent of Jesus and, with him, the Mahdī of the Prophet's family, already born and hidden in Twelver Shia belief, still to be born in the view of most Sunnis. Within the pairs the sources draw links of their own: the Gospels find Malachi's Elijah in John the Baptist, and the hadith set the returning Jesus beside a Muslim leader whom Shia and many Sunni scholars name the Mahdī. Setting all three side by side is the site's own comparison, and the figures differ on the very point of the card's subtitle: not all of them have been here before.
Side by side
Hebrew BibleMishnahJewish tradition
Malachi: “I will send you Elijah the prophet”
The Prophets close with a promise: “Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the LORD” (Malachi 4:5; 3:23 in Hebrew Bibles). Malachi names no Messiah; it is later Jewish tradition that sets Elijah before him. The Mishnah says Elijah will come to make peace in the world (Eduyot 8:7); at the close of the Sabbath Jews sing that he may come soon with the Messiah son of David; and a cup is poured for him at the Passover Seder and a chair set for him at every circumcision. These customs are told in Elijah's entry, “The guest at every Seder and circumcision”, and Malachi's, “The Great Sabbath and the cup of Elijah”.
Malachi 4:5–6 (Hebrew 3:23–24) · Mishnah Eduyot 8:7 · Jewish liturgy (Havdalah; Passover Haggadah)
Jewish tradition
Maimonides: the Messianic king
Maimonides (d. 1204) closes his code of law with two chapters on the Messiah (Laws of Kings 11–12). “In the future, the Messianic king will arise and renew the Davidic dynasty, restoring it to its initial sovereignty” (11:1, tr. E. Touger). He will build the Temple, gather the dispersed of Israel and restore the commandments, and “Anyone who does not believe in him or does not await his coming” denies the prophets and the Torah. He need not work wonders (11:3). A king of David's house who studies and keeps the Torah, leads Israel in it and fights God's wars may be presumed to be the Messiah; if he builds the Temple in its place and gathers the exiles, he is the Messiah for certain; if he fails or is killed, he was not (11:4). Elijah will come to “prepare their hearts”, and some sages say he comes before the Messiah; but “All these and similar matters cannot be definitely known by man until they occur”, the order of these things is no principle of faith, and “one should not try to determine the appointed time for Mashiach's coming” (12:2).
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11:1–4; 12:2 (tr. E. Touger, Chabad.org)
Jewish traditionHebrew Bible
“Though he tarry”: the twelfth principle and the daily prayer
In his commentary on the Mishnah (Sanhedrin 10) Maimonides counted the Messiah's coming as the twelfth of his thirteen principles of faith (see the Mahdī's entry, “Messiah, Second Coming, Saoshyant”). The later creed Ani Maamin, printed in many prayer books, gives it one line: “I believe with perfect faith in the coming of the Messiah, and, though he tarry, I will wait daily for his coming.” Its “though he tarry” is Habakkuk's: “though it tarry, wait for it; because it will surely come, it will not tarry” (Habakkuk 2:3). The Amidah, said three times on weekdays, asks: “Speedily cause the sprout of Your servant, David, to flourish and let his horn be exalted by Your salvation,” “for we wait for Your salvation daily.”
Maimonides, Commentary on the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 10 (the Thirteen Principles) · Ani Maamin (English as quoted in Christianity Today, 13 March 1970) · Habakkuk 2:3 · Amidah, 15th blessing (tr. as in My Jewish Learning, “National Redemption”)
TalmudHebrew BibleJewish tradition
Two Messiahs: son of Joseph and son of David
The Talmud knows a second figure. On the mourning of Zechariah 12:10, “they shall look upon me whom they have pierced, and they shall mourn for him”, the sages dispute: one view says it is for the slaying of the Messiah son of Joseph, the other for the slaying of the evil inclination. A teaching on the same page has God tell the Messiah son of David to ask of Him (Psalm 2:7–8); seeing the Messiah son of Joseph slain, he asks only for life (Sukkah 52a). Medieval apocalypses such as the Book of Zerubbabel made the son of Joseph a warrior who falls before the son of David comes (see Joseph's and Zerubbabel's entries, and “The false messiah”, where Armilus kills him). Maimonides' code knows one Messiah, of David's line.
Babylonian Talmud, Sukkah 52a · Zechariah 12:10 · Psalm 2:7–8 · Sefer Zerubbabel
New Testament
Acts: “this same Jesus … shall so come”
Luke's second book opens on the mount called Olivet (Acts 1:12). The disciples ask, “Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?” (1:6), and are told, “It is not for you to know the times or the seasons, which the Father hath put in his own power” (1:7). Then “he was taken up; and a cloud received him out of their sight”, and two men in white say: “Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing up into heaven? this same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven” (1:9–11). Peter later says that heaven must receive him “until the times of restitution of all things” (3:21). The one awaited is the one who left.
Acts 1:6–12; 3:21
New TestamentHebrew Bible
The Gospels: the Son of man coming in the clouds
Sitting on the Mount of Olives (Matthew 24:3), Jesus tells his disciples of the end: “For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be” (24:27), and “they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory” (24:30). The image is Daniel's, “one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven” (Daniel 7:13), and Jesus uses it again before the high priest (Matthew 26:64). The time is hidden: “But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only” (24:36); “Therefore be ye also ready: for in such an hour as ye think not the Son of man cometh” (24:44). He warns against those who will say, “Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not” (24:23). In John he promises, “I will come again, and receive you unto myself” (John 14:3).
Matthew 24:3, 23–44; 26:64 · Daniel 7:13 · John 14:3
Christian traditionNew TestamentChurch Fathers
The creeds and the prayer: “he shall come again”
The return entered the creeds. The Apostles' Creed: “From thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead”; the Nicene Creed, in its traditional English: “and He shall come again, with glory, to judge the quick and the dead; whose kingdom shall have no end.” The Catholic Catechism teaches that “Since the Ascension Christ's coming in glory has been imminent”, though the times are not ours to know (673). The prayer for it is older than the creeds. Paul ends a letter with the Aramaic Maranatha (1 Corinthians 16:22), which Kirsopp Lake explains as “Our Lord! Come!”; the Didache, an early church order, ends its thanksgiving with it: “Let grace come and let this world pass away. Hosannah to the God of David. … Maranatha, Amen” (Didache 10.6, tr. K. Lake). The Bible itself ends, “Even so, come, Lord Jesus” (Revelation 22:20).
Apostles' Creed (traditional English, CCEL) · Nicene Creed (traditional English, CCEL) · Catechism of the Catholic Church 673 · 1 Corinthians 16:22 · Didache 10.6 (tr. K. Lake, 1912) · Revelation 22:20
New TestamentChurch Fathers
“This is Elias, which was for to come”
The Gospels read Malachi's promise as fulfilled. Of John the Baptist Jesus says, “And if ye will receive it, this is Elias, which was for to come” (Matthew 11:14), and after the Transfiguration, “Elias is come already, and they knew him not … Then the disciples understood that he spake unto them of John the Baptist” (17:12–13); Elijah's and John's entries give John's own denial, “I am not” (John 1:21). In Christian reading the herald has come and so has the Messiah; what remains is his return. Yet the same passage also keeps a future: “Elias truly shall first come, and restore all things” (Matthew 17:11). Augustine (d. 430) reports the hope of Elijah in person before the end: “It is a familiar theme in the conversation and heart of the faithful, that in the last days before the judgment the Jews shall believe in the true Christ, that is, our Christ, by means of this great and admirable prophet Elias who shall expound the law to them” (City of God 20.29, tr. M. Dods). Early writers also made Enoch and Elijah the two witnesses of Revelation 11, who return to face the Antichrist (see Enoch's entry, “The two witnesses”).
Matthew 11:14; 17:10–13 · John 1:21 · Augustine, City of God 20.29 (tr. M. Dods, NPNF I.2) · Revelation 11:3–12
QurʾanTafsir
The Qurʾan: “he will be a witness” and “knowledge of the Hour”
The Qurʾan does not tell of Jesus's return in so many words; two verses are read as speaking of it. After “Allah took him up unto Himself” (Qurʾan 4:158) it says: “There is not one of the People of the Scripture but will believe in him before his death, and on the Day of Resurrection he will be a witness against them” (4:159). Al-Ṭabarī judged it likeliest that “his death” is Jesus's, still to come after his descent, and Ibn Kathīr reads it so; others, reported from Ibn ʿAbbās, Mujāhid and ʿIkrima, read it of each Jew or Christian at his own death; al-Qurṭubī judged these two readings the more apparent (aẓhar) without choosing between them. In Sūrat al-Zukhruf, after a passage on the son of Mary (43:57–59), comes: “And lo! verily there is knowledge of the Hour. So doubt ye not concerning it, but follow Me” (43:61). Pickthall leaves untranslated the pronoun of innahu, “he” or “it”. Ibn Kathīr takes it of Jesus: “The correct view concerning this phrase is that it refers to his descent before the Day of Resurrection” (in the English abridgement), and he cites the reading la-ʿalamun, “a sign”, for la-ʿilmun, “knowledge”; Mujāhid too glossed it as “sign”. Al-Ḥasan al-Baṣrī and Saʿīd b. Jubayr are reported as taking the pronoun to mean the Qurʾan.
Qurʾan 4:157–159; 43:57–61 · al-Ṭabarī, Jāmiʿ al-bayān (on 4:159) · Ibn Kathīr, Tafsīr (on 4:159; 43:61; English abridgement) · al-Qurṭubī, al-Jāmiʿ li-aḥkām al-Qurʾān (on 4:159) · A. A. Mawdūdī, Tafhīm al-Qurʾān (on 43:61)
Sunni hadithTafsir
The hadith: “the son of Mary will soon descend”
The hadith say it plainly. In al-Bukhārī the Prophet swears: “By Him in Whose Hands my soul is, surely (Jesus,) the son of Mary will soon descend amongst you and will judge mankind justly (as a Just Ruler); he will break the Cross and kill the pigs and there will be no Jizya” (Bukhārī 3448). The narrator, Abū Hurayra, joins it to the Qurʾan himself: “If you wish, you can recite (this verse of the Holy Book)”, and recites 4:159. The next report asks, “How will you be when the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends amongst you and your imam is among you” (Bukhārī 3449; wa-imāmukum minkum). Muslim adds that the Muslims' leader will invite him to lead the prayer and he will decline (Muslim 156), and tells of his descent at the white minaret east of Damascus and his killing of the Dajjāl (Muslim 2937); see Jesus's entry, “The return”, and “The false messiah”. Ibn Kathīr calls the hadith of the descent mutawātir, mass-transmitted.
Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3448, 3449 (English as on Sunnah.com) · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 156, 2937 · Ibn Kathīr, Tafsīr (on 43:61)
Sunni hadith
The Sunan: “whose father's name corresponds to my father's name”
The Mahdī is not named in the Qurʾan, nor in the Ṣaḥīḥs of al-Bukhārī and Muslim, though Muslim has the leader for whom Jesus declines to lead the prayer. His hadith are in the Sunan. Ibn Masʿūd reports that if only one day of the world remained, God would lengthen it until He sent a man of the Prophet's family “whose name corresponds to my name and whose father's name corresponds to my father's name” (yuwāṭiʾu smuhu smī wa-smu abīhi sma abī), who would fill the earth with justice “just as it was filled with injustice and oppression” (Abū Dāwūd 4282; al-Albānī: ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ). Abū Dāwūd's Kitāb al-Mahdī adds that “The Mahdi will be of my family, of the descendants of Fatimah” (4284; al-Albānī: ṣaḥīḥ) and gives his broad forehead and seven years' rule (4285; ḥasan); other reports in the chapter al-Albānī grades weak (4286–4288). Al-Tirmidhī has the hadith of Ibn Masʿūd with the name but without the father's name, “A man is coming from the people of my family whose name agrees with my name”, and calls it ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ (2231, with 2230). For more, and for al-Shawkānī's view that the reports are mass-transmitted, see the Mahdī's entry, “The Sunni hadith”.
Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4282–4288 (Kitāb al-Mahdī), with al-Albānī's gradings (as on Sunnah.com and HadithUnlocked) · Jāmiʿ al-Tirmidhī 2230–2231
Shia hadithShia tradition
The twelfth Imam: hidden and awaited
Twelver Shia hold that the Mahdī has already been born: Muḥammad, son of the eleventh Imam, born in Sāmarrāʾ in 255/869, withdrawn from sight at his father's death in 874, guiding through four deputies in the Minor Occultation until 941, and since then in the Major Occultation (see the Mahdī's entry). He is al-Muntaẓar, “the awaited”, and the waiting is itself a duty. In a report in al-Kāfī al-Bāqir counts waiting for the Qāʾim part of religion beside the confession of God's oneness, and in al-Ṣadūq's Kamāl al-dīn the one who dies waiting is likened to one who is with the Qāʾim in his tent, then to one who fought beside him with the sword, then to one martyred with the Prophet (as summarised by WikiShia). A saying given to ʿAlī runs: intaẓirū l-faraj wa-lā tayʾasū min rawḥ Allāh, fa-inna aḥabba l-aʿmāl ilā Allāh ʿazza wa-jalla intiẓār al-faraj, wait for relief and do not despair of God's mercy, for the deed God loves most is waiting for relief (as cited from al-Majlisī's Biḥār al-anwār). After blessings on the Prophet and his family Shia commonly add wa-ʿajjil farajahum, “and hasten their relief”, understood as a prayer for the Imam's appearance.
al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 2:22 · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn, p. 338 · WikiShia, “Intizar al-Faraj” · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār (as cited on the forum of the al-ʿAbbās shrine, forums.alkafeel.net, node 141697) · WikiShia, “ʿAjjil farajahum”
Shia hadithQurʾan
“And to make them the inheritors”
Shia tradition reads the Qurʾan's promise to the oppressed as pointing to the rule of the Prophet's family at the end. In Nahj al-balāgha, the collection of ʿAlī's words made by al-Sharīf al-Raḍī (d. 1015), ʿAlī says: “The world will bend towards us after having been refractory as the biting she-camel bends towards its young”, and then recites Qurʾan 28:5, in Pickthall's English, “And We desired to show favour unto those who were oppressed in the earth, and to make them examples and to make them the inheritors”; the word Pickthall gives as “examples”, aʾimma, is the plural of imām. In its context the verse speaks of the Children of Israel under Pharaoh (28:4–6). The Mahdī's title Baqiyyat Allāh is likewise taken from Qurʾan 11:86 (see the Mahdī's entry, “Names and titles”).
Nahj al-balāgha, saying 209 (tr. Sayyid ʿAlī Riḍā, as on hadith.net) · Qurʾan 28:4–6; 11:86
Who draws the link
New TestamentSunni hadithSunni tradition
The site's comparison, and the pairs within it
The card is marked “observed”, and the marker stands: no scripture, hadith or commentary found for this entry sets the Jewish Messiah, the returning Christ and the Mahdī side by side as one hope. Each later tradition does draw a link to an earlier one. The Gospels take up the Jewish expectation and say it is fulfilled: the herald of Malachi is John (Matthew 11:14), and the Messiah is Jesus, “We have found the Messias” (John 1:41). The hadith take up the Christian expectation in a Muslim form: Jesus returns, breaks the cross, and stands beside the Muslims' leader (Bukhārī 3448–3449; Muslim 156). A version in the Musnad of al-Ḥārith b. Abī Usāma (d. 896), quoted by Ibn al-Qayyim in al-Manār al-munīf, who calls its chain good (jayyid), names that leader al-Mahdī; the version in Muslim does not name him, and Shia tradition and many Sunni commentators, such as al-Munāwī, identify him as the Mahdī (see Jesus's entry, “Jesus prays behind the Mahdī”).
Matthew 11:14 · John 1:41 · Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3448–3449 · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 156 · al-Ḥārith b. Abī Usāma, Musnad, via Ibn al-Qayyim, al-Manār al-munīf (as cited in ʿAbd al-Muḥsin al-ʿAbbād, al-Radd ʿalā man kadhdhaba bi-l-aḥādīth al-ṣaḥīḥa al-wārida fī l-Mahdī, and in “The Critique of Criticism: Analysis of Ibn Khaldun's Objections to the Narrations about al-Mahdi”, icraa.org) · al-Munāwī, Fayḍ al-qadīr (as cited in IslamWeb, fatwa 172455)
Jewish tradition
Maimonides: three faiths and one Messiah
The one source found here that places all three faiths in a single messianic frame does so from one side. In a passage of the Laws of Kings removed by censors from most printed editions (see Jesus's entry, “Not the Messiah”), Maimonides, after rejecting Jesus's claim, writes: “All those words of Jesus of Nazareth and of this Ishmaelite [i.e., Muhammad] who arose after him are only to make straight the path for the messianic king and to prepare the whole world to serve the Lord together” (as given in A. J. Rudin, Christians & Jews Faith to Faith, 2010), by spreading knowledge of scripture and its commandments. For Maimonides the Christian and Muslim hopes serve the Jewish one; he grants neither of their figures.
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11 (uncensored text; 11:10–12 in some numberings), tr. A. J. Rudin, as quoted in Wikipedia, “Jewish views on Muhammad”
Sunni tradition
Ibn Khaldūn: the Mahdī and Jesus together
Ibn Khaldūn (d. 1406) opens his chapter on the Mahdī in the Muqaddima with the common belief: “It has been well known (and generally accepted) by all Muslims in every epoch that at the end of time a man from the family (of the Prophet) will without fail make his appearance”; “He will be called the mahdī.” “Following him, the antichrist … will appear”, and Jesus will descend and kill him; “Or, Jesus will descend together with the mahdī, and help him kill (the antichrist)” (tr. F. Rosenthal). He then examines the hadith chain by chain and concludes, “Very few are above criticism.” A modern Sunni study of his objections (W. A. Cheema, after a treatise of Ashraf ʿAlī Thānawī) notes that he accepts as sound two reports of Muslim, of a caliph who hands out wealth without counting it, and that he does not quote Muslim's report of Jesus and the leader at prayer.
Ibn Khaldūn, al-Muqaddima 3 (tr. F. Rosenthal, 1958), as quoted in K. S. Aghaie, “Messianism: Messianism in the Muslim Tradition”, Encyclopedia of Religion (2nd ed., 2005) · “The Critique of Criticism: Analysis of Ibn Khaldun's Objections to the Narrations about al-Mahdi” (icraa.org)
History
Modern scholarship
Modern scholars treat the three hopes under one name, messianism. The Encyclopedia of Religion has a single article “Messianism” with sections for each tradition; its Muslim section, by Kamran Scot Aghaie, notes that “the Islamic scripture conceives of a messiah somewhat differently from the Jewish and Christian traditions”, since the Qurʾan gives the title masīḥ to Jesus alone. Abdulaziz Sachedina called his study of the Twelver doctrine Islamic Messianism (1981), and Mohamed Osman Salih's Edinburgh dissertation of 1976 studied “Mahdīsm in Islam up to 260 a.h./874 a.d. and Its Relation to Zoroastrian, Jewish, and Christian Messianism”. Questions of influence among the traditions are debated by scholars (see the Mahdī's entry, “Messiah, Second Coming, Saoshyant”); the site makes no claim of borrowing.
K. S. Aghaie, “Messianism: Messianism in the Muslim Tradition”, Encyclopedia of Religion (2nd ed., 2005) · A. Sachedina, Islamic Messianism (1981) · M. O. Salih, “Mahdīsm in Islam up to 260 a.h./874 a.d. and Its Relation to Zoroastrian, Jewish, and Christian Messianism” (PhD diss., Edinburgh, 1976)
Where they differ
New TestamentQurʾanSunni hadithHebrew BibleJewish traditionShia tradition
Awaited, or returning
The card's subtitle, “The one who returns”, fits only some of its figures. Christians await one who has come before: “this same Jesus” (Acts 1:11). Muslims await the same Jesus, raised alive (Qurʾan 4:158; Bukhārī 3448). Elijah, taken up in a whirlwind (2 Kings 2:11), is awaited to return in Judaism, and in Christian reading has already come in John. But the Jewish Messiah has not come before: Maimonides' king of David's house “will arise” (Laws of Kings 11:1), a man known by what he achieves (11:4). Nor, for most Sunnis, has the Mahdī: he is a man of the Prophet's family yet to be born. For Twelver Shia he was born in 869 and is hidden, and his coming is an appearance (ẓuhūr) from occultation, not a return; Shia doctrine keeps the word return (rajʿa) for those of the righteous and the wicked who will come back to life in his days (see the Mahdī's entry, “The rising”). The title, “The awaited one”, fits all; the subtitle is changed here to “The one who is to come”, after the question John's disciples put to Jesus, “Art thou he that should come, or do we look for another?” (Matthew 11:3).
Acts 1:11 · Qurʾan 4:158 · Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3448 · 2 Kings 2:11 · Matthew 11:3, 14 · Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11:1–4 · Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4282 · al-Mufīd, al-Irshād
TalmudMidrash
A hidden Messiah in the rabbis
Jewish tradition comes closest to a deliverer born and hidden in stories, not in law. The Jerusalem Talmud tells that on the day the Temple was destroyed an Arab passer-by told a Jew at his plough that the Messiah had been born, Menahem son of Hezekiah, in Bethlehem; the man went to sell swaddling clothes to the mother, and when he came back she told him that the child had been carried off by winds and a storm (Jerusalem Talmud, Berakhot 2:4, 5a; a variant in Lamentations Rabbah on 1:16). The Babylonian Talmud lists Menahem among the names proposed for the Messiah (Sanhedrin 98b), and places the Messiah among the poor at the gate of Rome, ready to come “today” if Israel will hear (Sanhedrin 98a; see the Mahdī's entry, “The Messiah at the gates of Rome”). These are aggadah; the Messiah of Maimonides' code is a king who arises, and Jewish creed asks no belief in a Messiah already alive.
Jerusalem Talmud, Berakhot 2:4 (5a) · Lamentations Rabbah 1:16 §51 · Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 98a–b · M. Attali, “A co-produced tradition about the Messiah and his mother in late antique rabbinic literature” (coproduced-religions.org, 2024) · Wikipedia, “Menahem ben Hezekiah”
Jewish traditionNew TestamentChurch FathersQurʾanShia hadithSunni hadith
Who heralds him
Malachi's Elijah is the herald of Jewish expectation, but not every authority fixed the order: Maimonides says only that some sages hold Elijah will come before the Messiah, and that the order of events is no principle of faith (Laws of Kings 12:2). The Gospels say the herald has come, in John (Matthew 17:12–13), while keeping a later coming of Elijah (17:11), which Augustine reports as a common Christian hope. Islam has no Elijah herald. The Qurʾan's Ilyās is a messenger who called his people away from Baal, with no word of a return (Qurʾan 37:123–132), and the stories of him alive with al-Khiḍr are popular ones that Ibn Kathīr rejected (see Elijah's entry, “Is he still alive?”). The signs before the Mahdī in Shia hadith are events, not a prophet: the Sufyānī, the Yamānī, the cry from heaven, the killing of the Pure Soul, the army swallowed in the desert (see the Mahdī's entry, “Signs”). In the Sunni hadith the descent of Jesus is itself one of the signs of the Hour (Muslim 2901).
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 12:2 · Matthew 17:10–13 · Augustine, City of God 20.29 · Qurʾan 37:123–132 · Ibn Kathīr, Qiṣaṣ al-anbiyāʾ (Ilyās) · al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-Ghayba · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2901
TalmudHebrew BibleNew TestamentSunni hadithShia hadith
One figure or two
Jewish texts can have two Messiahs, the son of Joseph who falls and the son of David who prevails (Sukkah 52a), though Maimonides' code knows one. Christianity has one figure who is both the slain one and the coming one: the Gospels read the pierced one of Zechariah 12:10 and the Son of man of Daniel 7:13 as Jesus (John 19:37; Matthew 24:30; see Zechariah's entry, “The king on an ass and the pierced one”). Islam has two figures with different roles: the Mahdī, of the Prophet's family, who leads the Muslims and fills the earth with justice, and Jesus, a prophet sent before, who descends, breaks the cross and, in the Sunni hadith, kills the Dajjāl, and who defers to the Muslims' leader at prayer (Muslim 156). Shia reports give the killing of the Dajjāl to the Mahdī or to Jesus; the deceiver is on “The false messiah”.
Babylonian Talmud, Sukkah 52a · Zechariah 12:10 · Daniel 7:13 · John 19:37 · Matthew 24:30 · Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3448 · Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 156, 2937 · al-Majlisī, Biḥār al-anwār 52
Jewish traditionChristian traditionSunni hadithQurʾan
Within history, or at its end
What the coming brings differs. Maimonides' Messiah restores David's kingdom, rebuilds the Temple, gathers the exiles and restores the commandments (Laws of Kings 11:1); the sages and prophets longed for his days not to “have dominion over the entire world”, but to be free for the Torah and its wisdom (12:4). It is an age within history. Christ comes again “to judge the quick and the dead”, and his kingdom “shall have no end” (Nicene Creed): his return closes history and opens the judgement. The Islamic hopes stand between: the Mahdī and Jesus fill the earth with justice for a reign the hadith count in years (seven, in Abū Dāwūd 4285), and after them come the Hour and the Resurrection, on whose day, the Qurʾan says, Jesus will be a witness against the People of the Scripture (Qurʾan 4:159).
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11:1; 12:4 (tr. E. Touger) · Nicene Creed · Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4285 · Qurʾan 4:159
Jewish traditionChristian traditionSunni hadithSunni traditionShia tradition
Creed, or report
The three hopes rest on texts of different standing. In Judaism the Messiah's coming is a principle of faith in Maimonides' list and a petition of the daily prayer. For Christians the return is in scripture and in the creeds of nearly all churches. In Islam Jesus's return rests on the Qurʾan as most commentators read it and on hadith in al-Bukhārī and Muslim that Ibn Kathīr calls mass-transmitted. The Mahdī rests on hadith of the Sunan, graded sound or good by most Sunni critics, while a minority have doubted them: Ibn Khaldūn found “very few” above criticism, and in the 20th century Rashīd Riḍā, in Tafsīr al-Manār, argued that the reports contradict one another. A report in Ibn Mājah has the Prophet say that there is no Mahdī but Jesus son of Mary (wa-lā l-mahdī illā ʿĪsā bnu Maryam, Ibn Mājah 4039), but Sunni critics reject it: the Darussalam edition grades it weak, al-Dhahabī calls it munkar, “rejected”, and so does al-Albānī. For Twelver Shia, by contrast, the hidden Imam belongs to the doctrine of the imamate itself, which holds that the earth is never without a proof of God (see the Mahdī's entry, “Why he is hidden”).
Maimonides, Commentary on the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 10 · Nicene Creed · Ibn Kathīr, Tafsīr (on 43:61) · Ibn Khaldūn, al-Muqaddima 3 (tr. F. Rosenthal) · “Criticizing the View of Rashid Reza on the Conflict of Mahdism's Traditions” (magiran.com, paper 1958839) · Sunan Ibn Mājah 4039 (Darussalam grading as on Sunnah.com) · al-Dhahabī, Mīzān al-iʿtidāl 3:535; al-Albānī, Silsilat al-aḥādīth al-ḍaʿīfa 77 (as cited in IslamQA, no. 34890) · al-Ṭūsī, Kitāb al-Ghayba
QurʾanJewish traditionChristian traditionBaháʼí
Whose figure is whose
The three names do not map onto one another. Christians call Jesus the Messiah, the Christ, and hold that the Messiah of the prophets has come; Judaism holds that he has not (see Jesus's entry, “Not the Messiah”). The Qurʾan too calls Jesus al-Masīḥ, “the Messiah”, but “only a messenger of Allah” (Qurʾan 4:171), and the hadith call the deceiver al-Masīḥ al-Dajjāl (see “The false messiah”). The Mahdī bears no title of messiah in Islam, and has no place in Jewish or Christian belief. Later movements claimed to fulfil several of these hopes at once: Mīrzā Ghulām Aḥmad claimed to be both the Mahdī and the promised Messiah, and Baháʼís hold that the Báb fulfilled the promise of the Qāʾim and Baháʼuʼlláh the promise of Christ's return (see the Mahdī's entry, “Mahdīs in history” and “The Báb and Baháʼuʼlláh”, and Jesus's entry).
Qurʾan 4:171 · Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11 · Y. Friedmann, Prophecy Continuous (1989) · Baháʼuʼlláh, Kitáb-i-Íqán
More parallels
Jewish traditionNew TestamentShia tradition
Prayers for the coming
Each tradition prays for the coming in fixed words. The Amidah asks on every weekday, morning, afternoon and evening, that God “speedily cause the sprout of Your servant, David, to flourish”, and at the close of the Sabbath Jews sing for Elijah to come with the Messiah son of David (see Elijah's entry). Christians pray “Thy kingdom come” in the Lord's Prayer (Matthew 6:10), and the Aramaic Maranatha and “Even so, come, Lord Jesus” (Revelation 22:20) ask for the return itself. Shia add “and hasten their relief” after blessings on the Prophet's family, and pray the Duʿāʾ al-Nudba and Duʿāʾ al-ʿAhd for the Imam (see the Mahdī's entry, “Prayers of waiting”). These are liturgy of long standing in each tradition, not reports of one source.
Amidah, 15th blessing · Jewish liturgy (Havdalah) · Matthew 6:10 · 1 Corinthians 16:22 · Revelation 22:20 · WikiShia, “ʿAjjil farajahum” · Ibn al-Mashhadī, al-Mazār al-kabīr
Hebrew BibleNew TestamentQurʾanJewish traditionShia tradition
Taken up alive
The figures who are awaited to come back left the earth alive, and their leaving is told in like words. Elijah “went up by a whirlwind into heaven” (2 Kings 2:11). Of Jesus, Acts says “he was taken up; and a cloud received him out of their sight” (Acts 1:9), and the Qurʾan that “Allah took him up unto Himself” (Qurʾan 4:158). A rabbinic list of those who entered Paradise alive names Enoch, Elijah and the Messiah together (see Enoch's entry, “Among those who entered Paradise alive”); Christians made Enoch and Elijah the two witnesses of the last days; and Muslims add al-Khiḍr, widely held to be alive, whom a report in Kamāl al-dīn makes the hidden Imam's companion (see “Joseph and the Mahdī”, “Al-Khiḍr at the pilgrimage”). Shia writers cite all of these in defence of the Imam's long life (see the Mahdī's entry, “A very long life” and “The ones who did not die”), and al-Ṣadūq tells of an occultation of Idrīs, Enoch, which ends with his return to promise a deliverer (see Enoch's entry, “Enoch, Elijah and the hidden one”).
2 Kings 2:11 · Acts 1:9 · Qurʾan 4:158 · Revelation 11:3–12 · al-Ṣadūq, Kamāl al-dīn
New TestamentTalmudShia hadith
Present, and not known
Twelver Shia hold that the hidden Imam walks among people who do not recognise him, as Joseph's brothers did not know him; the reports are on “Joseph and the Mahdī”. The Gospels say the same of Elijah come in John, “Elias is come already, and they knew him not” (Matthew 17:12), and the Talmud's Messiah sits unrecognised among the poor at the gate of Rome (Sanhedrin 98a). The awaited one, in each, may already be near.
Matthew 17:12 · Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 98a · al-Nuʿmānī, Kitāb al-ghayba, ch. 10
Jewish traditionNew TestamentTalmudShia hadithHistory
Those who claimed to be the one
Each tradition has met men who claimed, or were proclaimed, to be the awaited one, and each sets a test. Maimonides recalls that Rabbi Akiva took Bar Kozibah (Bar Kokhba) for the Messiah and the sages asked him for no signs (Laws of Kings 11:3); what decides is whether the king achieves the Messiah's work (11:4). Jesus warns, “Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not” (Matthew 24:23). Islamic history has its Mahdīs, from the founder of the Fāṭimids to the Sudanese Mahdī, and both Sunni and Twelver scholars rejected them (see the Mahdī's entry, “Mahdīs in history”). And all three warn against fixing the date: the Talmud curses those who calculate the end, Jesus says no one knows the day, and al-Ṣādiq that “the time-setters lie” (see the Mahdī's entry, “Do not calculate the end”).
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings 11:3–4 · Matthew 24:23, 36 · Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 97b · al-Kulaynī, al-Kāfī 1 (Bāb karāhiyat al-tawqīt) · W. Madelung, “al-Mahdī”, EI2